August 19, 2003 - LA Times: RPCV says New school testing takes the U.S. closer to 'Old Europe'

Peace Corps Online: Peace Corps News: Headlines: Peace Corps Headlines - 2003: August 2003 Peace Corps Headlines: August 19, 2003 - LA Times: RPCV says New school testing takes the U.S. closer to 'Old Europe'

By Admin1 (admin) on Friday, August 29, 2003 - 10:40 am: Edit Post

RPCV says New school testing takes the U.S. closer to 'Old Europe'





Read and comment on this story from the LA Times by RPCV Jonathan Zimmerman who says that when he joined the Peace Corps, posted as an English teacher in Nepal, he arrived with a characteristic American blend of zeal and naiveté. Rather than simply drilling my students in the required curriculum, he resolved, he would teach them how to think.
"Yet whenever I introduced a game or a song or anything outside of the official course of study the students bridled. "Sir," they complained, "this is not on the SLC."

The SLC was the School Leaving Certificate examination, which all Nepalese had to pass to qualify for higher education and lucrative government jobs. Although Nepal was never colonized by the West, its school system closely resembled neighboring India and other former imperial outposts. To get anywhere in life, you had to get past the SLC.

My Peace Corps friends and I often commiserated about the evils of the test. It made students anxious; it encouraged rote instruction; it fostered cheating. As I wrote in a letter home, the SLC was "the worst educational legacy that Europe gave to the world."

Little did I know that the U.S. would embrace this legacy two decades later. At last count, 24 U.S. states require or plan to require that students pass exit exams to earn high school diplomas. Under President Bush's No Child Left Behind Act, meanwhile, states will have to administer annual tests in six elementary and junior high grades. In our schools, the U.S. is becoming more like Donald Rumsfeld's "Old Europe" than many of us care to admit."
That's not necessarily a bad development. For too long, many American schools have operated with low standards, or with no standards at all. If we craft the new exams with care and act upon their results, the tests might spur student learning. Or, as I saw in Nepal, they might simply spawn more corruption, cynicism and rote instruction.

For good or ill, though, the new education reforms will make us more like other countries, especially European ones. Even as we turn our noses up at the rest of the world, our schools are starting to emulate it. Read the story at:


Making the Grade*

* This link was active on the date it was posted. PCOL is not responsible for broken links which may have changed.



Making the Grade

New school testing takes the U.S. closer to 'Old Europe'

COMMENTARY

By Jonathan Zimmerman, Jonathan Zimmerman teaches history and education at New York University.

Twenty years ago this fall, I joined the Peace Corps. Posted as an English teacher in Nepal, I arrived with a characteristic American blend of zeal and naiveté. Rather than simply drilling my students in the required curriculum, I resolved, I would teach them how to think.

Yet whenever I introduced a game or a song or anything outside of the official course of study the students bridled. "Sir," they complained, "this is not on the SLC."

The SLC was the School Leaving Certificate examination, which all Nepalese had to pass to qualify for higher education and lucrative government jobs. Although Nepal was never colonized by the West, its school system closely resembled neighboring India and other former imperial outposts. To get anywhere in life, you had to get past the SLC.

My Peace Corps friends and I often commiserated about the evils of the test. It made students anxious; it encouraged rote instruction; it fostered cheating. As I wrote in a letter home, the SLC was "the worst educational legacy that Europe gave to the world."

Little did I know that the U.S. would embrace this legacy two decades later. At last count, 24 U.S. states require or plan to require that students pass exit exams to earn high school diplomas. Under President Bush's No Child Left Behind Act, meanwhile, states will have to administer annual tests in six elementary and junior high grades. In our schools, the U.S. is becoming more like Donald Rumsfeld's "Old Europe" than many of us care to admit.

Remember Old Europe? For the most part, Bush and Rumsfeld would prefer that you forgot it. On issues from arms control and the environment to the World Court and the war in Iraq, the White House has repeatedly flouted or ignored our putative allies across the Atlantic.

When it comes to education, however, the U.S. has moved in a remarkably European direction. Bush and his followers have demanded public vouchers for parochial schools, a mainstay of many European democracies for a century. Most of all, though, both the federal government and the states are requiring new high-stakes tests that put Old Europe to shame.

Consider two children, one who grows up in Massachusetts and another in Britain. Already, to graduate from high school, the Massachusetts student must pass the English and math portions of the state's school-leaving test. Starting with the 2005-06 school year, federal law will require her to take reading and math exams every year from third grade through eighth. Her school will have to report its annual results; if it does not show sufficient improvement, she will become eligible to transfer elsewhere.

The British student, by contrast, will have to take exams only three times: at ages 7, 11 and 14. The first set of tests is graded within each school, and the results are kept private; the second set is marked by external reviewers, with the results still private. Only the third exam, also graded externally, is reported to the public. The worst-performing schools then face a variety of sanctions, including the replacement of their staffs.

Defenders of high-stakes testing in the U.S. might point out that Massachusetts devises its own tests, whereas Britain administers a single nationwide exam. True enough. But other European countries allow more local flexibility. In Germany, for example, state education ministries write their own questions for the national exam that qualifies students for university.

Still other countries differentiate their examinations according to academic disciplines. All French candidates for higher education take the same national test in core subjects, but they also choose additional exams in an area of concentration: liberal arts, social sciences and so on.

Given our history of local control in education, it's hard to imagine the U.S. requiring a single national test. But our desire to require high school leaving tests no matter who writes them has already eroded a distinctive American educational tradition, bringing us closer to the European model.

That's not necessarily a bad development. For too long, many American schools have operated with low standards, or with no standards at all. If we craft the new exams with care and act upon their results, the tests might spur student learning. Or, as I saw in Nepal, they might simply spawn more corruption, cynicism and rote instruction.

For good or ill, though, the new education reforms will make us more like other countries, especially European ones. Even as we turn our noses up at the rest of the world, our schools are starting to emulate it.

If you want other stories on this topic, search the Archives at latimes.com/archives.




Click on a link below for more stories on PCOL

8/17/03
Call your Senator in August

Minnesota Sen. Coleman
Minnesota RPCVs should call Senator Norm Coleman and ask him to introduce an amendment to the Senate Foreign Operations Bill for President Bush's full $359M Peace Corps appropriation. RPCVs from other states should call their Senators and ask them to support the amendment.
More Stories from the August Issue of PCOL Magazine

Greater Accountability at the Peace Corps
Senator Norm Coleman is a strong supporter of Bush's full $359M budget request but wants greater accountability from the Peace Corps. Read why.

Send in the Peace Corps to Iraq?
See if you agree with the op-ed from the NY Times on embedding the Peace Corps with the military in Iraq.

House of Representatives passes Charter
The Peace Corps and the Returned Volunteer community celebrated a big victory when the "Peace Corps Act for the 21st Century" Act passed the House in July. Read what's next for the bill.

Kevin Quigley named new NPCA President
The NPCA has selected the next generation of leadership for their organization. Read about the new President.

Investigation on death of PCV in Mali
The results of the investigation into the death of PCV Zachary Merrill in Mali.

President Bush meets PCVs in Botswana
The President met with PCVs in Botswana. Here's what he said.

Friends of Liberia issue a Call to Action
This RPCV group has a long history on involvement in efforts to bring peace to their Country of Service. Here's what they have to say about the present situation.

More Feature Stories from Recent Issues of PCOL Magazine

Issues with the Peace Corps Bill in Congress
Read about the differences between the House and Senate versions of the "Peace Corps Act for the 21st Century" and decide which one is better.

Americorps' Failure
Lessons the Peace Corps can learn from Americorps' problems.

RPCVs dump ton of coal at US Capital
Read what the RPCV-led Chesapeake Climate Action Network is doing to educate the public on Global Warming.

German Peace Corps celebrates 40 years
The governance structure of the German Peace Corps differs from that of the US Peace Corps. Is it better?

Peace Corps to add 1,000 AIDS/HIV volunteers
Director Vasquez's new initiative to expand the Peace Corps in Africa.

Op-ed: The Future of the Peace Corps
Does the Peace Corps have a future in the age of the American Imperium? What do you think?

RPCV is wheelchair basketball champion
The courage of a volunteer struck down by polio in Central America.

Watch Director Vasquez on web tv
See the Peace Corps Director speak to High School students in Maryland.

The Digital Freedom Initiative
The innovative new program to wire Senegal.

Bill Moyers on America's Future
Read what an early Peace Corps Deputy Director says about America's future.

The Shrivers: A Special Legacy
The Founding Director of the Peace Corps and his future plans.


For the Record: Top Stories in the last 30 days
RPCVs work to end Female Genital Mutilation 17 Aug
RPCV runs river guide business in Alask 17 Aug
Somber reminders of danger 16 Aug
RPCV helps poor Guatemalan village 15 Aug
A Modest Proposal 13 Aug
Kennedy/Shriver connections help Arnold 13 Aug
RPCV dies in Uzbekistan 12 Aug
RPCV fined for protesting Iraq war 12 Aug
DRI sends Medical Supplies to Iraq 11 Aug
RPCV teaches Christian martial arts 11 Aug
Maria Shriver: Beauty and The Barbarian 10 Aug
RPCV is new Riverkeeper 10 Aug
Shrivers and Kennedys mum on Arnold 9 Aug
RPCV drops out of CA Governor's race 9 Aug
RPCV exhibits Palestinian Posters 9 Aug
They Will Remember 8 Aug
Vasquez in Ukraine 8 Aug
Senator Coleman and PC Appropriations 7 Aug
RPCV seeks California governor's office 7 Aug
Farewell from Dane Smith 6 Aug
PC Announces University Partnerships 6 Aug
This is Malaria 5 Aug
RPCV sees deprivation and dignity in Africa 5 August
USDA honors RPCV for Heifer Intl work 4 August
Ghana RPCV returns to help leprosy victims 4 August
RPCV and spouse work to end Liberia civil war 4 August
Memorial Fund established for RPCV 4 August
PCV hits the road in recumbent bicycle 3 Aug
PCV met President Bush in Botswana 1 August
Don't Mind the Goats 1 Aug
PC celebrates anniversary in East Timor 31 July
RPCV is new director of San Isabel Foundation 31 July
Parents recall PCV Zack Merrill 30 July
The AmeriCorps Follies 30 July
RPCV writes "What India means to me" 29 July
RPCV says Liberians want American aid 29 July
Vasquez to speak in Mexico 29 July
AmeriCorps Violated Budget Law 28 July
War-Zone Peace Corps? 27 July
Peace Corps good for America 27 July
Investigation on death of PCV 25 July
House passes $314M PC Appropriation 24 July
Send in the Peace Corps 23 July
Peace Corps to Reopen in Jordan 22 July
Peace Corps Writers announce awards 22 July
Call Now - Disaster ahead for PC Budget 21 July
Changing face of the Peace Corps 20 July
Older Volunteers Heed the Call to Volunteer 19 July
PC to get $49M less than requested 17 July
Top Discussion Stories

A Modest Proposal
Read the op-ed by John Coyne on how to expand and revitalize the NPCA and what you can do to help.

Send in the Peace Corps?
Should the Peace Corps be heading into Iraq and Afghanistan? What do you think?

Peace Corps Charter
Read about the new Peace Corps bill going through Congress. Compare the Senate and House versions of the bill here.

A Volunteer's Courage
After Sara Evans was assaulted she left the Peace Corps and returned to the United States. But her ordeal was only beginning.

The Fourth Goal
Read what Sargent Shriver says ought to be the Peace Corps' new goal for the 21st century.

The Numbers Game
Double the Peace Corps - but maintain the quality of the programs and the volunteer experience.

Improvements needed
...in Volunteer services. Read our exclusive story on what needs to be done to support volunteers and reduce attrition rates.

Volunteer Safety
Read the GAO Report on Safety and Security of Volunteers.

The Lariam Files
Read about the anti-malarial drug thousands of volunteers have taken - and its potential side effects.

Accountability
Senator Norm Coleman is a strong supporter of Bush's full $359M budget request but wants greater accountability from the Peace Corps. Read why.

Protest at the Peace Corps
Do volunteers and staff retain first amendment rights while working in the Peace Corps. Join the discussion.

RPCVs organize
Read how 1,800 RPCVs organized to place two half-page ads in the New York Times.

PC is "truly hardcore"
A Marine Sergeant visited his daughter who is serving in Nicaragua. Read what he says about the Peace Corps.

From Russia with Love
The story behind the departure of the Peace Corps from Russia.

RPCVs honor Vaughn
Returned Volunteers met to honor and listen to the wisdom of Peace Corps legend Jack Vaughn.

More Special Reports

The IDPA: PC Forerunner
The IDPA, a forerunner of the Peace Corps, created in 1951 to place people with indigenous organizations and governments in Africa, Asia, and Latin America.

Alcohol Abuse a big issue for PCVs in Central Asia
Read about the health hazard PC Staff is warning volunteers in former Soviet Republics about.

PC/Washington: Senior Staff Appointments at PC HQ
See if you can guess how many RPCVs there are in senior staff positions at PC Headquarters.

RPCV Spy dies in Moscow
The strange story of the RPCV who defected to Russia.

The Case for PC Independence
Why the USA Freedom Corps doesn't make sense.

Preservation of an Independent Peace Corps
Returned Volunteers insist that the Peace Corps must remain an independent agency to do its job.



Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.

This story has been posted in the following forums: : Headlines; COS - Nepal; Speaking Out; Secondary Education

PCOL7328
75

.


Add a Message


This is a public posting area. Enter your username and password if you have an account. Otherwise, enter your full name as your username and leave the password blank. Your e-mail address is optional.
Username:  
Password:
E-mail: