April 7, 2005: Headlines: Figures: Staff: Politics: City Government: Election2005 - Hardberger: San Antonio Current: Julian Castro issued a press release calling for Schubert to "end dirty campaign tactics," and defended his opponent: "Judge Hardberger is a good man. To try and discredit him this way is disgraceful."
Peace Corps Online:
Peace Corps News:
Library:
Peace Corps: Staff:
Staff and the Peace Corps:
April 7, 2005: Headlines: Figures: Staff: Politics: City Government: Election2005 - Hardberger: San Antonio Current: Julian Castro issued a press release calling for Schubert to "end dirty campaign tactics," and defended his opponent: "Judge Hardberger is a good man. To try and discredit him this way is disgraceful."
Julian Castro issued a press release calling for Schubert to "end dirty campaign tactics," and defended his opponent: "Judge Hardberger is a good man. To try and discredit him this way is disgraceful."
Julian Castro issued a press release calling for Schubert to "end dirty campaign tactics," and defended his opponent: "Judge Hardberger is a good man. To try and discredit him this way is disgraceful."
The phantom push poll
By Susan Pagani
04/07/2005
Candidates point fingers, citizens ponder
The infamous push poll of February: Some say it never existed. Others claim it lived as surely as the Yeti, but died when the voting public turned their cheek on moral turpitude and focused on real issues. Many are still trying to sort out what happened, and who was the real victim: Julian Castro, Phil Hardberger, or Carroll Schubert?
On a Wednesday evening in February, Philip Cortez, Castro's campaign manager, answered the telephone at his girlfriend's house. The caller asked for a registered voter and Cortez, who says he had "heard stories about a push poll," got a notebook and transcribed the 44-question, 828-word poll in its entirety. "I had to ask her to repeat everything several times," says Cortez. "But she was very nice; we were laughing and making jokes about some of the statements. She wasn't suspicious at all."
If I told you that...
• Judge Phil Hardberger likes to kick puppies
• Julian Castro dodged the Vietnam draft
• Carroll Schubert routinely mows his lawn on air quality health alert days
How likely would you be to vote for him?
The push poll controversy revolves around questions in which the pollster reportedly said she was going to read him "some points about the candidates," then ask him whether they would make him more or less likely to vote for them. Of 22 questions, only five relate to Schubert and Castro, the rest are negative statements about Hardberger, accusing him of everything from not paying his taxes and suing a Little League baseball team to being out of favor with President Bush and vowing to raise property taxes. The few statements about his opponents seem relatively innocuous: "Julián Castro is a councilman from the West Side, and is focused on bringing high-tech jobs and a higher quality of life to residents" or "Carroll Schubert's campaign is being funded by developers and lobbyists."
When, Cortez hung up the phone with the pollster, he immediately contacted Castro, who issued a press release calling for Schubert to "end dirty campaign tactics," and defended his opponent: "Judge Hardberger is a good man. To try and discredit him this way is disgraceful."
So why isn't the Hardberger campaign thankful?
"When it comes to the push poll ... there are a lot of questions on both Schubert's and Castro's sides," says Christian Archer, Hardberger's campaign manager. "I'm not sure there ever was a push poll."
Archer says the poll Cortez transcribed does not fit the profile of a classic push poll, which is designed to change opinions, not measure them. Unlike a legitimate poll, which contacts a small, representative sampling, a push poll calls thousands of voters. While a legitimate poll will describe the candidates' negative and positive characteristics to gauge voter reaction, a push poll will focus on negatives, sometimes stretching the truth. Because they aren't gathering statistics and responses from the voter, push polls tend to be shorter: "A push poll is four questions, not 44," Archer says.
Archer also takes issue with Castro's decision to publicize the poll. "Here's the real problem," he says. "There was Castro vouching for Judge Hardberger's integrity æ as if he needed to, as if the Judge hadn't been the chief justice of the Fourth Court of Appeals æ while he was handing out copies of [the poll]. Then he says, Sorry Judge, I only handed it to the media." Although no local media outlets published the entire poll, TJ Connolly, unofficial adviser for the Castro campaign, posted it on the website, sanantoniolightning.com.
"It's the oldest game in the book," says Scott Pool, Schubert's campaign manager, "make an accusation and then force your opponent to refute it. If we deny it, well then, all of a sudden the burden of proof falls to us. The only campaign that was never vetted about their motives was the Castro campaign."
Castro and the media initially criticized Schubert for steadfastly declining to comment on whether Schubert was polling at the time of the alleged push poll; nor would Schubert reveal the contents of his polls. "We don't want to tip our hand to the opposition, we said that even pre-push poll incident," Pool says, "I can categorically and emphatically deny that [the Schubert campaign] has ever done a push poll."
Pool and Archer also wonder why no voters have publicly corroborated Cortez' story. "One of the radio personalities on KPFA was begging people to call in and complain, but I don't think anyone ever called them, even after two or three days," says Pool.
Kevin Allen, a software engineer at Southwest Research Institute, says he was push polled around the same time as Cortez. His experience sheds no light on the phantom push poll, however, because the questions he remembers don't appear on the poll transcribed by Cortez.
Pool gives Castro "kudos for creative negative campaigning," but says the specter of push polling is not haunting Schubert's campaign. "It did for a week or so, but now I think the campaign and the voters have moved on."
"In the end," adds Archer, "[the push poll allegations] had a negative impact on Castro's campaign. We exposed a dirty trick, and I think a lot of people were offended by it." •
By Susan Pagani
©San Antonio Current 2005
When this story was posted in April 2005, this was on the front page of PCOL:
Peace Corps Online The Independent News Forum serving Returned Peace Corps Volunteers
| The Peace Corps Library Peace Corps Online is proud to announce that the Peace Corps Library is now available online. With over 30,000 index entries in 500 categories, this is the largest collection of Peace Corps related stories in the world. From Acting to Zucchini, you can find hundreds of stories about what RPCVs with your same interests or from your Country of Service are doing today. If you have a web site, support the "Peace Corps Library" and link to it today. |
| RPCVs and Friends remember Pope John Paul II Tony Hall found the pope to be courageous and capable of forgiving the man who shot him in 1981, Mark Gearan said the pope was as dynamic in person as he appears on television, Maria Shriver said he was a beacon of virtue, strength and goodness, and an RPCV who met the pope while serving in the Solomon Islands said he possessed the holiness of a man filled with a deep love and concern for humanity. Leave your thoughts here. |
| Friends of the Peace Corps 170,000 strong 170,000 is a very special number for the RPCV community - it's the number of Volunteers who have served in the Peace Corps since 1961. It's also a number that is very special to us because March is the first month since our founding in January, 2001 that our readership has exceeded 170,000. And while we know that not everyone who comes to this site is an RPCV, they are all "Friends of the Peace Corps." Thanks everybody for making PCOL your source of news for the Returned Volunteer community. |
| Crisis Corps arrives in Thailand After the Tsunami in Southeast Asia last December, Peace Corps issued an appeal for Crisis Corps Volunteers and over 200 RPCVs responded. The first team of 8 Crisis Corps volunteers departed for Thailand on March 18 to join RPCVs who are already supporting relief efforts in Sri Lanka, Indonesia, Thailand, Malaysia, and India with other agencies and NGO's. |
| RPCVs in Congress ask colleagues to support PC RPCVs Sam Farr, Chris Shays, Thomas Petri, James Walsh, and Mike Honda have asked their colleagues in Congress to add their names to a letter they have written to the House Foreign Operations Subcommittee, asking for full funding of $345 M for the Peace Corps in 2006. As a follow-on to Peace Corps week, please read the letter and call your Representative in Congress and ask him or her to add their name to the letter. |
| Add your info now to the RPCV Directory Call Harris Publishing at 800-414-4608 right away to add your name or make changes to your listing in the newest edition of the NPCA's Directory of Peace Corps Volunteers and Former Staff. Then read our story on how you can get access to the book after it is published. The deadline for inclusion is May 16 so call now. |
| March 1: National Day of Action Tuesday, March 1, is the NPCA's National Day of Action. Please call your Senators and ask them to support the President's proposed $27 Million budget increase for the Peace Corps for FY2006 and ask them to oppose the elimination of Perkins loans that benefit Peace Corps volunteers from low-income backgrounds. Follow this link for step-by-step information on how to make your calls. Then take our poll and leave feedback on how the calls went. |
Read the stories and leave your comments.
Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.
Story Source: San Antonio Current
This story has been posted in the following forums: : Headlines; Figures; Staff; Politics; City Government; Election2005 - Hardberger
PCOL19733
85
.