2006.06.29: June 29, 2006: Headlines: Figures: COS - Paraguay: Politics: City Government: Pittsburgh Post Gazette: On three occasions former Pittsburgh Mayor Tom Murphy was within days of being indicted by a federal grand jury

Peace Corps Online: Directory: Paraguay: Special Report: Paraguay RPCV Tom Murphy, Mayor of Pittsburgh: June 26, 2005: Index: PCOL Exclusive: Tom Murphy (Paraguay) : 2006.06.29: June 29, 2006: Headlines: Figures: COS - Paraguay: Politics: City Government: Pittsburgh Post Gazette: On three occasions former Pittsburgh Mayor Tom Murphy was within days of being indicted by a federal grand jury

By Admin1 (admin) (adsl-69-150-133-223.dsl.okcyok.swbell.net - on Friday, July 07, 2006 - 10:32 am: Edit Post

On three occasions former Pittsburgh Mayor Tom Murphy was within days of being indicted by a federal grand jury

On three occasions former Pittsburgh Mayor Tom Murphy was within days of being indicted by a federal grand jury

Essentially, Mr. Murphy's lawyers, led by former U.S. Attorney Harry Litman, talked the Department of Justice out of prosecuting their client, alternately arguing that the government had no case to bring, could not win whatever case it brought, and could even face a suit to recover any costs incurred by the former mayor if he were brought to trial and acquitted. Thomas Murphy, Jr., former Mayor of the City of Pittsburgh, PA , served as a Peace Corps Volunteer in Paraguay in the 1970's.

On three occasions former Pittsburgh Mayor Tom Murphy was within days of being indicted by a federal grand jury

How Murphy's lawyers faced down feds

Tuesday, June 27, 2006
By Dennis B. Roddy, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette

On three occasions, the latest a tense Jan. 27 meeting between defense lawyers and federal prosecutors, former Pittsburgh Mayor Tom Murphy was within days of being indicted by a federal grand jury.

Repeatedly, Mr. Murphy's defense lawyers faced down prosecutors, finally talking them out of seeking an indictment and working out an agreement not to prosecute.

Essentially, Mr. Murphy's lawyers, led by former U.S. Attorney Harry Litman, talked the Department of Justice out of prosecuting their client, alternately arguing that the government had no case to bring, could not win whatever case it brought, and could even face a suit to recover any costs incurred by the former mayor if he were brought to trial and acquitted.

The talks, detailed in defense documents obtained by the Post-Gazette, began in March of last year, in the midst of a grand jury probe, and continued well into this year, long after the grand jury's term had expired and more than a year after most witnesses had been interviewed.

Mr. Murphy's escape from indictment throws a light on an area of criminal defense practice that, by its very nature, is rarely seen outside closed conference rooms.

"Every now and then you win a lottery ticket," said Robert Bennett, a prominent criminal defense lawyer who earlier this year managed to prevent an indictment of KPMG, a major accounting firm implicated in a series of fraudulent tax shelters.

"Ninety percent of my practice is to prevent my clients from being charged," Mr. Bennett said.

The art of indictment prevention involves, as it did in Mr. Murphy's case, lengthy meetings that often end ambiguously, and waivers of ordinary protections such as the statute of limitations. In some instances, defense lawyers travel to Washington to present arguments that, while they can prevent indictment, can also tip the government's hand to the kind of defense their quarry intends to present.

In Mr. Murphy's case, all of those things happened.

Mr. Murphy's case was inadvertently helped, prosecution sources now say, as a result of lawyers and FBI agents refocusing their sights on Cyril H. Wecht, the nationally renowned forensic pathologist and former Allegheny County coroner. Indeed, according to letters from a member of Mr. Murphy's defense team, U.S. Attorney Mary Beth Buchanan's aides said they were delaying a decision on Mr. Murphy while they focused on another public official. Staff members inside the office of Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr. also said Ms. Buchanan had deferred a decision in the Murphy case until Dr. Wecht could be charged.

Even as draft indictments were drawn up in the final months of Mr. Murphy's term as mayor, Ms. Buchanan's deputies debated among themselves about whether an indictment would cross the boundaries of law enforcement into the realm of setting a new and wide-ranging public policy on how cities could be governed.

The maneuvers that kept Mr. Murphy from being indicted appeared to have two pivotal moments, the first in March of 2005, and the second six months ago.

A memorandum shows Mr. Litman and co-counsel David Hickton forestalled indictment in 2005 by traveling to Washington and presenting Justice Department officials with a lengthy memorandum outlining arguments against bringing charges.

In that memo, dated March 29, 2005, Mr. Litman and Mr. Hickton meticulously picked apart a proposed indictment of Mr. Murphy on charges that he deprived city residents of "the intangible right of honest services."

Saying that an interpretation of the theft of honest services statute "requires the government to show either bribery or the concealment of a financial interest that state law requires be disclosed," the two lawyers argued that an indictment would amount to prosecutors making public policy more rightly held by elected government officials.

Such an interpretation, they said, "would expose state and local political officials to possible federal prosecution in countless cases of common political bartering," the men wrote.

"Given the proposed indictment's interpretation of Section 1346, it is particularly instructive to note that the theory on which it is based -- that it is a federal crime to take official action in return for a political endorsement -- has been rebuffed by the United States' General Accounting Office, an arm of Congress," the men told Justice officials.

They cited several instances of Republican officeholders whose decisions could become subject to prosecution if Mr. Murphy's presumed trade of a contract for an endorsement were indictable.

They cited instances involving the mayors of Boston and Baltimore, as well as cases of political trading by New York Gov. George Pataki and candidates in the 2002 California gubernatorial race.

Mr. Litman and Mr. Hickton pointedly referenced a 2004 decision by President Bush to take no action to renew the federal ban on so-called assault weapons after the National Rifle Association publicly stated it would withhold its endorsement of a presidential candidate until the ban had expired.

Prosecutors held back after that meeting, only to flirt three months later with bringing a prosecution. It did not materialize, despite a heads-up to defense lawyers that such an indictment was forthcoming.

Then came a Jan. 27 meeting between prosecutors and the defense team at the U.S. attorney's office in Pittsburgh. It broke up amid the most explicit threat to date to indict the former mayor.

A Feb. 1 e-mail by Mr. Litman, followed up five days later by a registered letter to Ms. Buchanan, outlined the Jan. 27 meeting. Prosecutors, the documents say, informed Mr. Murphy's legal team that they planned to indict the former mayor on three felony counts and two misdemeanor counts.

The charges were different from the earlier theft of honest services accusation and would, instead, have been based on a federal statute forbidding a promise of benefits in return for political help.

Attending the meeting were Mr. Hickton and attorney Robert Leight, as well as Deputy U.S. Attorney Robert Cessar and Assistant U.S. Attorney Stephen Stallings. Lawrence Claus, a deputy Allegheny County district attorney who was overseeing the county's end of the joint state-federal probe, also attended.

Prosecutors Cessar and Stallings, according to an e-mail by Mr. Litman to Ms. Buchanan, offered a plea bargain: The former mayor, they said, could plead guilty to a single federal misdemeanor.

"Bob and Steve further suggested that if the mayor did not accept the offer, they would shortly seek a five-count indictment consisting of three felony charges ... and two misdemeanor charges," Mr. Litman wrote.

At one point, according to participants, Mr. Claus informed the legal team of several state charges Mr. Zappala was considering if the federal government did not act.

"It was not clear to the participants in the meeting whether they were speaking for you or simply setting out what they would be recommending you do," Mr. Litman wrote to Ms. Buchanan.

When Mr. Litman did not hear back from Ms. Buchanan, he and Mr. Hickton fired off a registered letter, marked "Personal and Confidential." The three-page letter pleaded for an opportunity to take the matter to the Justice Department criminal division in Washington for a second review by its top deputy attorney general before an indictment was brought.

Mr. Litman made clear that a plea bargain was out of the question.

In the Feb. 6 letter, the two lawyers also vividly suggested that the Supreme Court and the federal 3rd Circuit Court of Appeals "have repeatedly refused -- often with stinging language -- to endorse expansive statutory interpretations that would arrogate to federal prosecutors the sort of wide-ranging criminal-law oversight of local elections and political processes that you are seeking."

He also invoked the federal Hyde Amendment, which allows those exonerated by juries to seek reimbursement of legal costs.

As the Murphy legal team braced itself for a forthcoming indictment, expecting it as early as Feb. 13, they received a call back from Ms. Buchanan, who opened negotiations that would stretch from mid-February to yesterday.

Early in the process, the Murphy team persuaded the former mayor to waive the federal statute of limitations. Prosecutors were basing their criminal case on a Feb. 28, 2001, letter in which Joe King, head of the firefighters union, laid out "the full understanding of the parties" about the forthcoming contract settlement.

With a five-year statute about to run out and prosecutors threatening to charge their client, the Murphy lawyers decided to gamble that they could persuade Ms. Buchanan not to bring charges, but knew they had to keep her talking.

Yesterday, in an interview, Ms. Buchanan confirmed that Mr. Murphy had waived the statute of limitations. She never made clear whether her deputies, when they laid out the indictment threat against Mr. Murphy in January, were acting on her authority.

She said only, "I make the decisions on indictments."

When this story was posted in July 2006, this was on the front page of PCOL:

Contact PCOLBulletin BoardRegisterSearch PCOLWhat's New?

Peace Corps Online The Independent News Forum serving Returned Peace Corps Volunteers
Jody Olsen is acting Peace Corps Director Date: June 30 2006 No: 920 Jody Olsen is acting Peace Corps Director
The Senate confirmed Gaddi Vasquez to head the FAO on June 30. Jody Olsen will be acting Director until the President makes a permanent appointment. Olsen has been Deputy Director of the Peace Corps since 2002. She has previously served as Chief of Staff for two directors, as regional director for North Africa, Near East, and Asia and the Pacific, and as country director in Togo. She served in Tunisia as a PCV.

Top Stories and Breaking News PCOL Magazine Peace Corps Library RPCV Directory Sign Up

The Peace Corps Library Date: February 24 2006 No: 798 The Peace Corps Library
The Peace Corps Library is now available online with over 40,000 index entries in 500 categories. Looking for a Returned Volunteer? Check our RPCV Directory. New: Sign up to receive PCOL Magazine, our free Monthly Magazine by email. Like to keep up with Peace Corps news as it happens? Sign up to recieve a daily summary of Peace Corps stories from around the world.

Changing the Face of Hunger Date: June 28 2006 No: 915 Changing the Face of Hunger
In his new book, Former Congressman Tony Hall (RPCV Thailand) says humanitarian aid is the most potent weapon the United States can deploy against terrorism. An evangelical Christian, he is a big believer in faith-based organizations in the fight against hunger. Members of Congress have recently recommended that Hall be appointed special envoy to Sudan to focus on ending the genocide in Darfur.

PC will not return to East Timor in 2006 Date: June 8 2006 No: 913 PC will not return to East Timor in 2006
Volunteers serving in East Timor have safely left the country as a result of the recent civil unrest and government instability. Latest: The Peace Corps has informed us that at this time, the Peace Corps has no plans to re-enter the country in 2006. The Peace Corps recently sent a letter offering eligible volunteers the opportunity to reinstate their service in another country.

Chris Dodd considers run for the White House Date: June 3 2006 No: 903 Chris Dodd considers run for the White House
Senator Chris Dodd plans to spend the next six to eight months raising money and reaching out to Democrats around the country to gauge his viability as a candidate. Just how far Dodd can go depends largely on his ability to reach Democrats looking for an alternative to Hillary Clinton. PCOL Comment: Dodd served as a Volunteer in the Dominican Republic and has been one of the strongest supporters of the Peace Corps in Congress.

The RPCV who wrote about Ben Hogan Date: June 6 2006 No: 912 The RPCV who wrote about Ben Hogan
Probably no RPCV has done more to further the Third Goal of the Peace Corps than John Coyne with the Peace Corps Writers web site and newsletter that he and Marian Haley Beil have produced since 1989. Now John returns to writing about his first love - golf in "The Caddie who knew Ben Hogan." Read an excerpt from his novel, an interview with the author and a schedule of his book readings in Maryland and DC this week.

Vasquez testifies before Senate Committee Date: June 3 2006 No: 905 Vasquez testifies before Senate Committee
Director Vasquez testifies before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee on his nomination as the new Representative to the United Nations Agencies for Food and Agriculture replacing Tony Hall. He has been the third longest serving Peace Corps Director after Loret Ruppe Miller and Sargent Shriver. PCOL Comment: Read our thanks to Director Vasquez for his service to the Peace Corps.

First Amendment Watch Date: May 4 2006 No: 883 First Amendment Watch
Maine Web Report hit with Federal Lawsuit
Website wins trademark suit against Jerry Falwell

Interview with a Hit Man Date: April 25 2006 No: 880 Interview with a Hit Man
RPCV John Perkins says that for many years he was an "economic hit man" in the world of international finance whose primary job was to convince less developed countries to accept multibillion dollar loans for infrastructure projects that left the recipient countries wallowing in debt and highly vulnerable to outside political and commercial interests. In this exclusive interview for "Peace Corps Online," Colombia RPCV Joanne Roll, author of Remember with Honor, talks to Perkins about his Peace Corps service, his relation with the NSA, "colonization" in Ecuador, the consequences of his work, why he decided to speak out, and what his hopes are for change.

PC Program in Chad temporarily suspended Date: April 14 2006 No: 872 PC Program in Chad temporarily suspended
Director Vasquez announced the temporary suspension of the Peace Corps program in Chad on April 14 and that all 29 Peace Corps volunteers have left the country. With a program dating back forty years (See Page 4 of the April 1966 "Peace Corps Volunteer"), RPCVs hope that volunteers can return to Chad as soon as the situation has stabilized. Congratulations to the Peace Corps for handling the suspension quickly and professionally.

Peace Corps stonewalls on FOIA request Date: April 12 2006 No: 869 Peace Corps stonewalls on FOIA request
The Ashland Daily Tidings reports that Peace Corps has blocked their request for information on the Volkart case. "After the Tidings requested information pertaining to why Volkart was denied the position on March 2 the newspaper received a letter from the Peace Corps FOIA officer stating the requested information was protected under an exemption of the act." The Dayton Daily News had similar problems with FOIA requests for their award winning series on Volunteer Safety and Security.

PCOL readership increases 100% Date: April 3 2006 No: 853 PCOL readership increases 100%
Monthly readership on "Peace Corps Online" has increased in the past twelve months to 350,000 visitors - over eleven thousand every day - a 100% increase since this time last year. Thanks again, RPCVs and Friends of the Peace Corps, for making PCOL your source of information for the Peace Corps community. And thanks for supporting the Peace Corps Library and History of the Peace Corps. Stay tuned, the best is yet to come.

History of the Peace Corps Date: March 18 2006 No: 834 History of the Peace Corps
PCOL is proud to announce that Phase One of the "History of the Peace Corps" is now available online. This installment includes over 5,000 pages of primary source documents from the archives of the Peace Corps including every issue of "Peace Corps News," "Peace Corps Times," "Peace Corps Volunteer," "Action Update," and every annual report of the Peace Corps to Congress since 1961. "Ask Not" is an ongoing project. Read how you can help.

RPCV admits to abuse while in Peace Corps Date: February 3 2006 No: 780 RPCV admits to abuse while in Peace Corps
Timothy Ronald Obert has pleaded guilty to sexually abusing a minor in Costa Rica while serving there as a Peace Corps volunteer. "The Peace Corps has a zero tolerance policy for misconduct that violates the law or standards of conduct established by the Peace Corps," said Peace Corps Director Gaddi H. Vasquez. Could inadequate screening have been partly to blame? Mr. Obert's resume, which he had submitted to the Peace Corps in support of his application to become a Peace Corps Volunteer, showed that he had repeatedly sought and obtained positions working with underprivileged children. Read what RPCVs have to say about this case.

Military Option sparks concerns Date: January 3 2006 No: 773 Military Option sparks concerns
The U.S. military, struggling to fill its voluntary ranks, is allowing recruits to meet part of their reserve military obligations after active duty by serving in the Peace Corps. Read why there is opposition to the program among RPCVs. Director Vasquez says the agency has a long history of accepting qualified applicants who are in inactive military status. John Coyne says "Not only no, but hell no!" and RPCV Chris Matthews leads the debate on "Hardball." Avi Spiegel says Peace Corps is not the place for soldiers while Coleman McCarthy says to Welcome Soldiers to the Peace Corps. Read our poll results. Latest: Congress passed a bill on December 22 including language to remove Peace Corps from the National Call to Service (NCS) military recruitment program

Why blurring the lines puts PCVs in danger Date: October 22 2005 No: 738 Why blurring the lines puts PCVs in danger
When the National Call to Service legislation was amended to include Peace Corps in December of 2002, this country had not yet invaded Iraq and was not in prolonged military engagement in the Middle East, as it is now. Read the story of how one volunteer spent three years in captivity from 1976 to 1980 as the hostage of a insurrection group in Colombia in Joanne Marie Roll's op-ed on why this legislation may put soldier/PCVs in the same kind of danger. Latest: Read the ongoing dialog on the subject.

Read the stories and leave your comments.

Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.

Story Source: Pittsburgh Post Gazette

This story has been posted in the following forums: : Headlines; Figures; COS - Paraguay; Politics; City Government


Add a Message

This is a public posting area. Enter your username and password if you have an account. Otherwise, enter your full name as your username and leave the password blank. Your e-mail address is optional.