2006.12.01: December 1, 2006: Headlines: COS - Jordan: Islamic Issues: Women's Issues: Samar Magazine: Jordan RPCV Maryum Saifee writes: The Trouble with Islam (Part 2)

Peace Corps Online: Directory: Jordan: Peace Corps Jordan : Peace Corps Jordan: Newest Stories: 2006.12.01: December 1, 2006: Headlines: COS - Jordan: Islamic Issues: Women's Issues: Samar Magazine: Jordan RPCV Maryum Saifee writes: The Trouble with Islam (Part 2)

By Admin1 (admin) (ppp-70-135-11-239.dsl.okcyok.swbell.net - 70.135.11.239) on Tuesday, February 27, 2007 - 7:31 am: Edit Post

Jordan RPCV Maryum Saifee writes: The Trouble with Islam (Part 2)

Jordan RPCV Maryum Saifee writes: The Trouble with Islam (Part 2)

"In Manji's analysis of Islam, she packages Islam into an oversimplified equation, which basically amounts to: Islam = Anti-Semitism + Misogyny + Tyranny. She adds that this equation is not limited to fundamentalist Islam, but rather "mainstream" Islam and while all religions have extremist tendencies, Islam is the only religion she views where fundamentalism is actually mainstream. To further simplify matters, she plugs the West into another neat equation: West = Religious Freedom + Women's Progress + Safe haven for Muslims. Her Huntington-style juxtaposition of Islam versus the West lacks depth and fails to account for the many realities that fall outside these neatly calculated equations.

In her black and white analysis, Manji ignores the gray. She fails to mention that in many Islamic countries, women have held positions as heads of state - Benazir Bhutto of Pakistan, Megawati Sukarnoputri of Indonesia, Begum Khalida Zia of Bangladesh. The West, which she heralds as a paradigm of women's progress, can boast of very few and in the US, not a single one. Our most recent Nobel Peace Prize winner, Shirin Ebadi, comes from Iran. So her assertion that women in Islamic countries are oppressed and disempowered is an overstatement. Of course gender-based discrimination and violence occur in Islamic countries, but these phenomena occur across all cultures and societies and to imply that Islamic oppression is more "barbaric" than Western oppression feeds into inaccurate, Orientalist stereotyping. "


Jordan RPCV Maryum Saifee writes: The Trouble with Islam (Part 2)

Reading The Trouble with Islam, Part 2

Troubled by Irshad Manji

By Maryum Saifee

This piece originally appeared in Samar 17

The Trouble with Islam : A Muslim's Call for Reform in Her Faith. By Irshad Manji. St. Martin's Press

"I appreciate that every faith has its share of literalists. Christians have their Evangelicals. Jews have the ultra-Orthodox. For God's sake, even Buddhists have fundamentalists. But what this book hammers home is that only in Islam is literalism mainstream." ... by Bernard Lewis? Nope. Samuel Huntington? Not quite! Robert Spencer? Wrong again. The statement above was authored by none of the usual, white Orientalist suspects. Irshad Manji, a queer, South Asian, Canadian, self-identifying Muslim woman is the latest to jump on the Islam-bashing for a buck bandwagon. Manji is not the first writer to capitalize on Islam-bashing, nor will she be the last, but the danger in her latest book is that she packages her anti-Islam message in the guise of a progressive, moderate Muslim voice of reason

After attending Manji's The Trouble with Islam book reading a few weeks ago at Coliseum Books in New York City, I felt compelled to respond to her book, a "letter to fellow Muslims," as a Muslim woman with a very different point of view. Manji's mission is to promote dialogue and in line with her mission, I intend to respond to not only the substance, or lack thereof, of her arguments, but also the danger in her message and her means of promotion.

In Manji's analysis of Islam, she packages Islam into an oversimplified equation, which basically amounts to: Islam = Anti-Semitism + Misogyny + Tyranny. She adds that this equation is not limited to fundamentalist Islam, but rather "mainstream" Islam and while all religions have extremist tendencies, Islam is the only religion she views where fundamentalism is actually mainstream. To further simplify matters, she plugs the West into another neat equation: West = Religious Freedom + Women's Progress + Safe haven for Muslims. Her Huntington-style juxtaposition of Islam versus the West lacks depth and fails to account for the many realities that fall outside these neatly calculated equations.

In her black and white analysis, Manji ignores the gray. She fails to mention that in many Islamic countries, women have held positions as heads of state - Benazir Bhutto of Pakistan, Megawati Sukarnoputri of Indonesia, Begum Khalida Zia of Bangladesh. The West, which she heralds as a paradigm of women's progress, can boast of very few and in the US, not a single one. Our most recent Nobel Peace Prize winner, Shirin Ebadi, comes from Iran. So her assertion that women in Islamic countries are oppressed and disempowered is an overstatement. Of course gender-based discrimination and violence occur in Islamic countries, but these phenomena occur across all cultures and societies and to imply that Islamic oppression is more "barbaric" than Western oppression feeds into inaccurate, Orientalist stereotyping.

At her book reading, she stated that she felt thankful to have not been born in an Islamic country because if she were a Muslim woman living in the Muslim world, she would not have such freedoms. Yet again, Manji glosses over the serious civil liberties infringements against Muslims that have happened in the US after 9/11 with the Patriot Act, 3,208 deportations, 6,483 detentions, 27,000 FBI interrogation raids, and widespread racial and religious profiling. Her native Canada even issued a travel advisory against visiting the US after a Canadian citizen was deported to Syria when he landed on US soil. No formal charges were brought against him, no connection to terrorist links his crime was being Muslim. In a climate where Muslims are being punished for being Muslim, her portrayal of the West as a safe haven for Muslims to speak freely and openly makes little sense. In fact, the targeting of Muslims by the US government has forced many Muslims into silence and encouraged those with differing opinions to censor their points of view for fear of negative repercussions.

The trouble with Irshad Manji is that her definition of Islam lacks specificity and her celebration of the West lacks critical honesty. She gives us personal anecdotes of her experiences with Islam and then equates Islam to the summation of those experiences. Had she narrowed her definition of Islam to include that of South Asian expatriates living in Canada and actually interviewed others, then perhaps her book would have been an insightful glimpse into the situation of Muslims in her community. To generalize her experience and say this is "Islam" and furthermore diagnose this "Islam" in her book is where Manji goes too far and at the expense of the Muslims she hopes to mobilize into a progressive reformist movement. By finger pointing and alienating Muslim community members with her emotionally-charged and virulent statements, she has not only neglected to offer a viable solution for Islamic reform, but also managed to give the Muslim moderates she claims to represent a bad name.

The "movement" Manji is trying to create via her book and interactive website, muslim-refusenik.com, is a disturbing reality that must be challenged by the moderate, progressive, Muslim voices she claims to represent. Given our post-9/11 climate of anti-Muslim fever, it is particularly irresponsible of Manji to propagate sensationalized anti-Islam stereotypes.

Maryum Saifee works for Forefront, a NY-based human rights organization (www.forefrontleaders.org) and recently returned from the Peace Corps in Jordan.




Links to Related Topics (Tags):

Headlines: December, 2006; Peace Corps Jordan; Directory of Jordan RPCVs; Messages and Announcements for Jordan RPCVs; Islamic Issues; Women's Issues





When this story was posted in February 2007, this was on the front page of PCOL:


Contact PCOLBulletin BoardRegisterSearch PCOLWhat's New?

Peace Corps Online The Independent News Forum serving Returned Peace Corps Volunteers
Subscribe to Peace Corps News Date: January 14 2007 No: 1059 Subscribe to Peace Corps News
Don't miss our new web site, Peace Corps News, for the latest news about the Returned Volunteer community and what is going on with the Peace Corps around the world. Subscribe to our news feed to get Peace Corps news delivered to your desk as it happens. Then visit the Peace Corps Library, History of the Peace Corps, the worldwide RPCV Directory or leave a message for the RPCV community on the RPCV Bulletin Board.

Top Stories and Breaking News PCOL Magazine Peace Corps Library RPCV Directory Sign Up

February 23, 2007: This Month's Top Stories Date: February 24 2007 No: 1070 February 23, 2007: This Month's Top Stories
Hill announces Draft Accord in North Korea Nuclear Talks 12 Feb
Dodd builds connections in New Hampshire 19 Feb
PCVs accused of counterinsurgency activities 19 Feb
Harris Wofford declares support for Obama 18 Feb
Tschetter becomes the first Director to visit Malawi 16 Feb
New Fellows Program at Yale University 15 Feb
Sidney Slover helps start donut production in Honduras 16 Feb
Kevin O'Donnell's Daughter and Granddaughter are PCVs 14 Feb
Joe Krueger helps restore Liberia's timber industry 14 Feb
Peace Corps Hippies 13 Feb
Maryland RPCVs to screen "American Idealist" on March 3 9 Feb
Aaron Kase writes: Moon over Africa 8 Feb
Margaret Krome writes: 'Rogue nations' aren't only threat 8 Feb
Shays says he would Support McCain 8 Feb
A Mistrial for Lieut. Watada 8 Feb
Chris Matthews drops the F-bomb 8 Feb
RPCVs - Believe it or not 07 Feb
White House requests $334 Million for Peace Corps 5 Feb
Carol Bellamy writes: We need an Earth Corps 3 Feb
First Group of PCVs arrive in Cambodia 2 Feb
Mae Jemison wears red for charity 2 Feb
Dear Miss Lonelyhearts 30 Jan

February 2, 2007: This Month's Top Stories Date: February 2 2007 No: 1063 February 2, 2007: This Month's Top Stories
Peace Corps Volunteers in Guinea Are Safe in Mali 28 Jan
Lee Wilbur writes: Muslim media images are shocking 31 Jan
Gregory Acker plays African drums for 3rd Goal 31 Jan
"Jimi Sir" now available for free internet viewing 30 Jan
Is Civilian Reserve just another Bush throwaway line? 30 Jan
Tony Hall writes: What North Korea really wants 30 Jan
Paul Tsongas remembered on 10th anniversary 28 Jan
Ben Bell attends Washington march against Iraq war 27 Jan
First Peace Corps Volunteers to Serve in Cambodia 26 Jan
Phil Hardberger sees 'golden years' ahead for San Antonio 26 Jan
Doyle wants smoking ban in Wisconsin 24 Jan
Mark Udall to run for Colorado Senate Seat 17 Jan
Meredith Walsh works with Burmese refugees 16 Jan
Tschetter spends MLK Day with Habitat for Humanity 15 Jan
Robert Buckley founds Himalayan Healers 14 Jan
James Rupert writes: An aging king in Thailand 14 Jan
Michael O'Hanlon writes: A Skeptic's Case For the Surge 14 Jan
Senator Dodd opposes Iraq surge 11 Jan
Pat Waak celebrates 2008 Democratic Convention 11 Jan
Al Kamen writes: The six rules for Congressional Junkets 10 Jan
Bill Moyers slams Bush on global warming 10 Jan
Psychological biases favor conflict rather than concession 1 Jan

The Peace Corps Library Date: July 11 2006 No: 923 The Peace Corps Library
The Peace Corps Library is now available online with over 40,000 index entries in 500 categories. Looking for a Returned Volunteer? Check our RPCV Directory or leave a message on our Bulletin Board. New: Sign up to receive our free Monthly Magazine by email, research the History of the Peace Corps, or sign up for a daily news summary of Peace Corps stories. FAQ: Visit our FAQ for more information about PCOL.

Chris Dodd's Vision for the Peace Corps Date: September 23 2006 No: 996 Chris Dodd's Vision for the Peace Corps
Senator Chris Dodd (RPCV Dominican Republic) spoke at the ceremony for this year's Shriver Award and elaborated on issues he raised at Ron Tschetter's hearings. Dodd plans to introduce legislation that may include: setting aside a portion of Peace Corps' budget as seed money for demonstration projects and third goal activities (after adjusting the annual budget upward to accommodate the added expense), more volunteer input into Peace Corps operations, removing medical, healthcare and tax impediments that discourage older volunteers, providing more transparency in the medical screening and appeals process, a more comprehensive health safety net for recently-returned volunteers, and authorizing volunteers to accept, under certain circumstances, private donations to support their development projects. He plans to circulate draft legislation for review to members of the Peace Corps community and welcomes RPCV comments.

He served with honor Date: September 12 2006 No: 983 He served with honor
One year ago, Staff Sgt. Robert J. Paul (RPCV Kenya) carried on an ongoing dialog on this website on the military and the peace corps and his role as a member of a Civil Affairs Team in Iraq and Afghanistan. We have just received a report that Sargeant Paul has been killed by a car bomb in Kabul. Words cannot express our feeling of loss for this tremendous injury to the entire RPCV community. Most of us didn't know him personally but we knew him from his words. Our thoughts go out to his family and friends. He was one of ours and he served with honor.

Meet Ron Tschetter - Our Next Director Date: September 6 2006 No: 978 Meet Ron Tschetter - Our Next Director
Read our story about Ron Tschetter's confirmation hearing before the Senate Foreign Relations Committee that was carried on C-Span. It was very different from the Vasquez hearings in 2001, very cut and dried with low attendance by the public. Among the highlights, Tschetter intends to make recruitment of baby boomers a priority, there are 20 countries under consideration for future programs, Senator Dodd intends to re-introduce his third goal Peace Corps legislation this session, Tschetter is a great admirer of Senator Coleman's quest for accountability, Dodd thinks management at PC may not put volunteers first, Dodd wants Tschetter to look into problems in medical selection, and Tschetter is not a blogger and knows little about the internet or guidelines for volunteer blogs. Read our recap of the hearings as well as Senator Coleman's statement and Tschetter's statement.

Peace Corps' Screening and Medical Clearance Date: August 19 2006 No: 964 Peace Corps' Screening and Medical Clearance
The purpose of Peace Corps' screening and medical clearance process is to ensure safe accommodation for applicants and minimize undue risk exposure for volunteers to allow PCVS to complete their service without compromising their entry health status. To further these goals, PCOL has obtained a copy of the Peace Corps Screening Guidelines Manual through the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) and has posted it in the "Peace Corps Library." Applicants and Medical Professionals (especially those who have already served as volunteers) are urged to review the guidelines and leave their comments and suggestions. Then read the story of one RPCV's journey through medical screening and his suggestions for changes to the process.

The Peace Corps is "fashionable" again Date: July 31 2006 No: 947 The Peace Corps is "fashionable" again
The LA Times says that "the Peace Corps is booming again and "It's hard to know exactly what's behind the resurgence." PCOL Comment: Since the founding of the Peace Corps 45 years ago, Americans have answered Kennedy's call: "Ask not what your country can do for you--ask what you can do for your country. My fellow citizens of the world: ask not what America will do for you, but what together we can do for the freedom of man." Over 182,000 have served. Another 200,000 have applied and been unable to serve because of lack of Congressional funding. The Peace Corps has never gone out of fashion. It's Congress that hasn't been keeping pace.

PCOL readership increases 100% Date: April 3 2006 No: 853 PCOL readership increases 100%
Monthly readership on "Peace Corps Online" has increased in the past twelve months to 350,000 visitors - over eleven thousand every day - a 100% increase since this time last year. Thanks again, RPCVs and Friends of the Peace Corps, for making PCOL your source of information for the Peace Corps community. And thanks for supporting the Peace Corps Library and History of the Peace Corps. Stay tuned, the best is yet to come.

History of the Peace Corps Date: March 18 2006 No: 834 History of the Peace Corps
PCOL is proud to announce that Phase One of the "History of the Peace Corps" is now available online. This installment includes over 5,000 pages of primary source documents from the archives of the Peace Corps including every issue of "Peace Corps News," "Peace Corps Times," "Peace Corps Volunteer," "Action Update," and every annual report of the Peace Corps to Congress since 1961. "Ask Not" is an ongoing project. Read how you can help.


Read the stories and leave your comments.






Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.

Story Source: Samar Magazine

This story has been posted in the following forums: : Headlines; COS - Jordan; Islamic Issues; Women's Issues

PCOL35322
59


Add a Message


This is a public posting area. Enter your username and password if you have an account. Otherwise, enter your full name as your username and leave the password blank. Your e-mail address is optional.
Username:  
Password:
E-mail: