2007.07.29: July 29, 2007: COS - Thailand: Sociology: Boston Globe: Charles Murray has turned against the SAT
Peace Corps Online:
Peace Corps Thailand:
Peace Corps Thailand: Newest Stories:
2007.07.29: July 29, 2007: COS - Thailand: Sociology: Boston Globe: Charles Murray has turned against the SAT
Charles Murray has turned against the SAT
He's convinced that the SAT provides little information about high school students not already provided by their grades and scores on so-called achievement tests, exams that are tied to specific academic subjects. And dumping the SAT would have numerous benefits: scuttling what he sees as a deceptive test-prep industry, undercutting the unproductive smugness that comes from thinking one's high SAT score reflects personal glory (he views it as the luck of the genetic draw), and short-circuiting the contention that the SAT amounts to a conspiracy against low-income students. "If the SAT had not acquired the role in American culture that it has, I'd say, 'Take the SAT, take the achievement tests, and who cares?'" Murray said in an interview. But the popular perception of the SAT as unfair and coachable -- even if that view is wrong -- "has a very corrosive effect." Charles Murray served as a Peace Corps Volunteer in Thailand in the 1960's.
Charles Murray has turned against the SAT
Charles Murray, erstwhile champion of the SAT, has changed his mind about the test -- and says it's time to scrap it
By Christopher Shea | July 29, 2007
Charles Murray has turned against the SAT. Yes, that Charles Murray.
The author of the controversial 1994 book "The Bell Curve" and champion of IQ tests might be the last person in the world you'd expect to object to a test that boils academic aptitude down to a couple of numbers burned into students' memories for life.
Yet Murray has just invigorated the anti-SAT cause with a manifesto titled "Abolish the SAT" in The American, a magazine published by the American Enterprise Institute, where he's a senior scholar. That the SAT is superfluous -- worse, outright bad for American education -- is "a conclusion I resisted as long as I could," Murray writes, partly for biographical reasons: He assumed his SAT scores carried him from his podunk Iowa high school into Harvard.
Now, however, he's convinced that the SAT provides little information about high school students not already provided by their grades and scores on so-called achievement tests, exams that are tied to specific academic subjects. And dumping the SAT would have numerous benefits: scuttling what he sees as a deceptive test-prep industry, undercutting the unproductive smugness that comes from thinking one's high SAT score reflects personal glory (he views it as the luck of the genetic draw), and short-circuiting the contention that the SAT amounts to a conspiracy against low-income students.
"If the SAT had not acquired the role in American culture that it has, I'd say, 'Take the SAT, take the achievement tests, and who cares?'" Murray said in an interview. But the popular perception of the SAT as unfair and coachable -- even if that view is wrong -- "has a very corrosive effect."
There have long been complaints about the test, but Murray's turnabout coincides with a surge in criticism of the SAT and its use by colleges. A University of California researcher, on whose earlier work Murray draws, released a study in June affirming that the SAT provides little additional information in California's admissions process. Meanwhile, an article in the newest American Sociological Review argues that admissions officers -- despite some assertions to the contrary -- are putting more weight on the SAT than ever. Murray's intervention could make a difference, given his reputation and his status in some conservative circles.
"The phrase that comes to mind is, 'Nixon going to China,'" said Howard Gardner, a professor of cognition and education at Harvard and a longtime SAT critic.
. . .
Murray's road-to-Damascus moment arrived when he came across research conducted in 2001 by the Office of the President of the University of California, when then-president Richard Atkinson floated the idea of ditching the SAT. Researchers Saul Geiser and Richard Studley found that the SAT, by itself, was not a bad predictor of freshman-year college grades. But if you considered high school GPA and three achievement-test scores -- and then looked at the extra predictive value added by the SAT, the SAT explained only an additional 0.1 percent of student performance differences.
Wayne Camara, the top researcher at the College Board, which administers the SAT, said that's a somewhat rigged way of looking at things: If you started with the SAT and GPA, and then looked at the achievement tests, they would appear to add relatively little value, too; College Board studies affirm that, on balance, SAT scores and achievement-test numbers are largely interchangeable.
But that's not true for all students -- or all achievement tests. On average, 30 percent of students will have statistically significant differences between their two sets of scores, Camara said. Colleges may want to know which students -- and by how much. And, he added, there are other confounding issues, as when native Spanish speakers take the Spanish-language achievement test.
(The College Board seemingly changes the names of its tests every few years, a fact that Murray and I both choose to ignore for the sake of clarity: What he calls the SAT and the achievement tests the College Board today calls the SAT Reasoning Test and the SAT Subject Tests.)
In 2001, the UC researchers found that achievement tests and high school GPA were powerful predictors of freshman-year college performance at even the weakest California high schools -- which sealed the deal for Murray. Last month, Geiser, now a fellow at Berkeley's Center for Studies of Higher Education, and co-author Maria Veronica Santelices, of Berkeley's Graduate School of Education, released a follow-up report showing that the 2001 findings were confirmed by the students' grades throughout their college years.
Prodded by the University of California, the College Board in 2005 made changes to the SAT. There is now a writing test and more upper-level algebra, and the infamous verbal-analogies section (the most IQ-like part of the test) has been dropped. Murray argues that the closer the SAT moves toward being an achievement test -- exactly what UC wanted -- the more superfluous it becomes.
Despite the concerns about the test, the American Sociological Review study identifies a major shift, from the 1980s to the 1990s, in how selective colleges evaluated applicants. Formerly, GPA mattered more than the SAT in admission, conclude Sigal Alon, of the University of Tel Aviv, and Marta Tienda, of Princeton. By the '90s, at the most selective colleges, the SAT was given more weight than GPAs, and the SAT's relative importance increased almost everywhere. And recent surveys suggest the trend continues.
Can one man's change of heart shift the SAT debate? Plenty of psychologists, including David Lohman of the Univerity of Iowa, continue to maintain that tests measuring "fluid reasoning" unconnected to specific curriculums are better than achievement tests at identifying smart kids in bad schools (though Lohman doesn't think the current SAT is a very good test of fluid reasoning). And numerous widely ignored studies have shown that SAT-like tests are not as coachable as test-prep companies claim they are.
If the SAT were abandoned, it's possible that test-coaching mania and the overall anti-testing brouhaha would simply shift to the achievement tests. But expensive cram-style courses, Murray writes, would be less alienating to low-income students than current beat-the-SAT boot camps, which give students who can't afford them "the sense of being shut out of mysteries."
Is this a never-ending debate? Maybe not, Murray said: If Harvard dropped the test, "the SAT would disappear almost instantly."
Christopher Shea's column appears regularly in Ideas. E-mail firstname.lastname@example.org. CHARLES MURRAY has turned against the SAT. Yes, that Charles Murray.
© Copyright 2007 Globe Newspaper Company.
Links to Related Topics (Tags):
Headlines: July, 2007; Sociology; Peace Corps Library; Peace Corps Directory; Peace Corps Original Sources; Bulletin Board; Recent Peace Corps News
When this story was posted in August 2007, this was on the front page of PCOL:
Peace Corps Online The Independent News Forum serving Returned Peace Corps Volunteers
| Senator Dodd's Peace Corps Hearings|
Read PCOL's executive summary of Senator Chris Dodd's hearings on July 25 on the Peace Corps Volunteer Empowerment Act and why Peace Corps Director Ron Tschetter does not believe the bill would contribute to an improved Peace Corps while four other RPCV witnesses do. Highlights of the hearings included Dodd's questioning of Tschetter on political meetings at Peace Corps Headquarters and the Inspector General's testimony on the re-opening of the Walter Poirier III investigation.
| Dodd issues call for National Service|
Standing on the steps of the Nashua City Hall where JFK kicked off his campaign in 1960, Presidential Candidate Chris Dodd issued a call for National Service. "Like thousands of others, I heard President Kennedy's words and a short time later joined the Peace Corps." Dodd said his goal is to see 40 million people volunteering in some form or another by 2020. "We have an appetite for service. We like to be asked to roll up our sleeves and make a contribution," he said. "We haven't been asked in a long time."
| Public diplomacy rests on sound public policy|
When President Kennedy spoke of "a long twilight struggle," and challenged the country to "ask not," he signaled that the Cold War was the challenge and framework defining US foreign policy. The current challenge is not a struggle against a totalitarian foe. It is not a battle against an enemy called "Islamofascism." From these false assumptions flow false choices, including the false choice between law enforcement and war. Instead, law enforcement and military force both must be essential instruments, along with diplomacy, including public diplomacy. But public diplomacy rests on policy, and to begin with, the policy must be sound. Read more.
| Ambassador revokes clearance for PC Director|
A post made on PCOL from volunteers in Tanzania alleges that Ambassador Retzer has acted improperly in revoking the country clearance of Country Director Christine Djondo. A statement from Peace Corps' Press Office says that the Peace Corps strongly disagrees with the ambassador’s decision. On June 8 the White House announced that Retzer is being replaced as Ambassador. Latest: Senator Dodd has placed a hold on Mark Green's nomination to be Ambassador to Tanzania.
| Peace Corps Funnies|
A PCV writing home? Our editor hard at work? Take a look at our Peace Corps Funnies and Peace Corps Cartoons and see why Peace Corps Volunteers say that sometimes a touch of levity can be one of the best ways of dealing with frustrations in the field. Read what RPCVs say about the lighter side of life in the Peace Corps and see why irreverent observations can often contain more than a grain of truth. We'll supply the photos. You supply the captions.
| PCOL serves half million|
PCOL's readership for April exceeded 525,000 visitors - a 50% increase over last year. This year also saw the advent of a new web site: Peace Corps News that together with the Peace Corps Library and History of the Peace Corps serve 17,000 RPCVs, Staff, and Friends of the Peace Corps every day. Thanks for making PCOL your source of news for the Peace Corps community. Read more.
| Suspect confesses in murder of PCV|
Search parties in the Philippines discovered the body of Peace Corps Volunteer Julia Campbell near Barangay Batad, Banaue town on April 17. Director Tschetter expressed his sorrow at learning the news. “Julia was a proud member of the Peace Corps family, and she contributed greatly to the lives of Filipino citizens in Donsol, Sorsogon, where she served,” he said. Latest: Suspect Juan Duntugan admits to killing Campbell. Leave your thoughts and condolences .
| Warren Wiggins: Architect of the Peace Corps|
Warren Wiggins, who died at 84 on April 13, became one of the architects of the Peace Corps in 1961 when his paper, "A Towering Task," landed in the lap of Sargent Shriver, just as Shriver was trying to figure out how to turn the Peace Corps into a working federal department. Shriver was electrified by the treatise, which urged the agency to act boldly. Read Mr. Wiggins' obituary and biography, take an opportunity to read the original document that shaped the Peace Corps' mission, and read John Coyne's special issue commemorating "A Towering Task."
| Chris Dodd's Vision for the Peace Corps|
Senator Chris Dodd (RPCV Dominican Republic) spoke at the ceremony for this year's Shriver Award and elaborated on issues he raised at Ron Tschetter's hearings. Dodd plans to introduce legislation that may include: setting aside a portion of Peace Corps' budget as seed money for demonstration projects and third goal activities (after adjusting the annual budget upward to accommodate the added expense), more volunteer input into Peace Corps operations, removing medical, healthcare and tax impediments that discourage older volunteers, providing more transparency in the medical screening and appeals process, a more comprehensive health safety net for recently-returned volunteers, and authorizing volunteers to accept, under certain circumstances, private donations to support their development projects. He plans to circulate draft legislation for review to members of the Peace Corps community and welcomes RPCV comments.
| He served with honor|
One year ago, Staff Sgt. Robert J. Paul (RPCV Kenya) carried on an ongoing dialog on this website on the military and the peace corps and his role as a member of a Civil Affairs Team in Iraq and Afghanistan. We have just received a report that Sargeant Paul has been killed by a car bomb in Kabul. Words cannot express our feeling of loss for this tremendous injury to the entire RPCV community. Most of us didn't know him personally but we knew him from his words. Our thoughts go out to his family and friends. He was one of ours and he served with honor.
Read the stories and leave your comments.
Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.
Story Source: Boston Globe
This story has been posted in the following forums: : COS - Thailand; Sociology