2010.03.08: Kenya RPCV Michael Fairbanks writes: Communists are Back in Africa

Peace Corps Online: Directory: Kenya: Peace Corps Kenya : Peace Corps Kenya: Newest Stories: 2010.03.08: Kenya RPCV Michael Fairbanks writes: Communists are Back in Africa

By Admin1 (admin) (151.196.10.59) on Wednesday, March 31, 2010 - 10:10 am: Edit Post

Kenya RPCV Michael Fairbanks writes: Communists are Back in Africa

Kenya RPCV Michael Fairbanks writes: Communists are Back in Africa

The Chinese have a ravenous appetite for natural resources to fuel their thousands of factories; and a debate rages in Western capitals over the merits of Chinese engagement with Africa. Ten U.S. congressmen toured Africa last month and nervously inquired about Chinese activities. Western activists protest that Chinese investment comes at the expense of democracy and human rights, and fosters corruption. There is merit to these concerns, but where is the introspection? Why is the relationship between the West and Africa shaped by one form of aid or another? President Paul Kagame of Rwanda states, "We should be debating why so little investment is made in the continent, not where it originates."

Kenya RPCV Michael Fairbanks writes: Communists are Back in Africa

Communists are Back in Africa

Africa was always the chessboard on which stronger nations played. But the productivity of capitalist nations proved greater than the putative power of the Soviet Union. The communists left Africa, and billboards proclaiming, "All Glory to the Revolution" were replaced by pithy aphorisms: "Democratize, Stabilize, Liberalize, and Privatize." These were important but insufficient prescriptions by what Nobel Laureate Joe Stiglitz said were "second-tier economists from first-rate universities."

Now, the communists are back. The Chinese have a ravenous appetite for natural resources to fuel their thousands of factories; and a debate rages in Western capitals over the merits of Chinese engagement with Africa. Ten U.S. congressmen toured Africa last month and nervously inquired about Chinese activities. Western activists protest that Chinese investment comes at the expense of democracy and human rights, and fosters corruption. There is merit to these concerns, but where is the introspection? Why is the relationship between the West and Africa shaped by one form of aid or another? President Paul Kagame of Rwanda states, "We should be debating why so little investment is made in the continent, not where it originates."

This may be about to change. A "Presidential Summit on Entrepreneurship" will be held this spring in Washington. It will be the highest-profile event ever regarding entrepreneurship and economic development, and will center on the relationship between the United States and Muslim communities, many of which are in Africa. This forum needs to be extended to all of Africa.

Most Aid Never has Impact

Eighty percent of assistance from the aid agencies, the not-for-profits, and the United Nations never achieves the desired goal; this is according to an aid agency that shelved their own report. Aid should be used in situations such as Haiti to mitigate the impact of natural disasters on vulnerable populations, but it has never been sufficient to lift nations out of poverty. In fact, there are reasons to believe the opposite.

The United Nations has 17,000 peace-keeping forces in Congo costing billions of dollars, but never addresses the underlying issues that caused the war: lack of governance, degrading poverty and intolerance. The U.N. Millennium Village program created high expectations, but failed to coordinate with national governments across Africa. They have programs for visitors that officials call "Poorism." Tourists pay to visit villages and buy small crafts and agricultural products. One official showed me a brochure that sets rules for the busloads of visitors. The first rule is, please do no not feed the villagers.

These places are less like the model villages of the new millennium and more like the Potemkin villages of the last millennium: Russian towns built like theatrical sets, with large fires that glowed in the distance to portray economic activity.

Not-for-profit organizations are uneven in their impact. Pioneers like Paul Farmer who founded Partners in Health, or Greg Mortenson of "Three Cups of Tea" fame, are respected for starting with only a vision.

Other not-for-profit leaders, especially some of those who refer to themselves as Social Entrepreneurs, claim they borrow the best ideas of the private sector, and focus on innovation to serve the poor. Yet, they often spend more money on public relations than on R&D and training their own staff; and they place their headquarters closer to media centers and the affluent rather than the needy. Their impact is tiny compared to the multilaterals, or faith-based initiatives, or even the development aid provided by the Pentagon.

The Gates Foundation's investments in health care and education promote a long-term perspective and catalyze others to solve some of the earth's biggest challenges. But investments in business environments may be different. According to a successful East African entrepreneur, Gates is "the elephant that tramples the grass." They invested so much money in coffee growing regions, for example, that they distorted incentives for local investors, forcing some to the sidelines. No one disputes that the Gates folks are smart, and have a heart as big as their endowment, but do they also have a mind for the poor?

Aid largesse can distort private initiatives, stifle democracies, amplify ethnic-based patron-client relationships, and promote corruption. Former Finance Minister of Afghanistan, Ashraf Ghani, who has been shortlisted to lead the U.N. and the World Bank, observes that aid can even "sever the sovereign relationship between people and their leaders."

There are features of successful aid programs: a shared vision by both the provider and recipient, disbursement through national institutions, investment that increases competence beyond applying for aid, and no parallel donor structures that undermine all of the above. According to some leaders in Africa, the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) is one of the worst at meeting these criteria; the U.K.'s DFID is the 'best of the West.'

Meanwhile, Shanghai hosted the African Development Bank meetings in 2007. Chinese Premier, Wen Jiabao, recently vowed to increase bilateral trade, extend zero-tariff treatment, provide interest-free loans to African nations, increase technology transfer, and to encourage his citizens to build sustainable businesses in Africa. Trade between Africa and China is already over USD 100 billion, though much of that is oil. The China Africa Development Fund has invested USD 540 million in 27 projects in Africa, and intends to invest USD 5 billion over the next few years in housing, energy, and industrial projects.

Africans have Choices

We are now in the mid-game: Many Africans believe that China values Africa and believes in its future more than the West. But the West can improve its position.

First, we need to value what Africans say: they don't intend to trade their independence for a relationship with China. Rwanda, for example, doesn't have to: GDP grew at 11.2% in 2008, and over 6% in the throes of 2009. Wages in key export sectors grew up to 30% each year since 2001. The country cut aid in half as a percentage of their budget, and was recognized as the top reformer in the world last year. Fifty-six percent of their legislature is women, which leads the world; women hold the key posts in the cabinet and judiciary; and free and closely scrutinized elections will be held again in August. Rwanda has a mutually respectful relationship with the Chinese, but theirs is not the Chinese model.

Second, the West should do what it can do better than anyone: focus on "Enterprise Solutions to Poverty." The greatest thing we could do to build international trust and help poor people is to stop protecting industries where the West has lost competitive advantages. We should broaden the definition of international security from geo-strategic to upgrading firm-level relationships between our societies; and, we should bond with the thousands of African entrepreneurs who are already successful and give them 'rocket fuel' by connecting them to global networks of productivity, trade and investment. The best way to create many new entrepreneurs is to show that great ones are already there to emulate.

The West remains attractive to Africans. We share a difficult history and some languages and culture. But we are no longer the only ones who shape the discussion there. Our paternalistic attitude toward Africa does not work because Africans now have choices.

China is the largest developing nation, and regards relations with other poor nations as the basis for its entire foreign policy. Their leaders are sober, goal-oriented and have a long-term perspective. Our foreign aid vision lacks coherence, is uninformed, does not balance the past with the future, and is over-influenced by donor fashions and sentimentality concocted by PR executives with skinny passports.

I look forward to the U.S.A.'s Presidential Summit on Entrepreneurship. I hope future summits will cover all of Africa, and focus not on top-down solutions, or massive infusions of aid, or what the rest of the world should think or do, but on our own values and attitudes and what we can do better. We need to check our vanity and condescension, and look deeper for underlying causes and for the unanticipated consequences of our own strategies.

We need a better metaphor than the chessboard to explain a new approach to Africa. We should have a discussion for the times in which we live, be open to learn from the Africans, and focus on what we can do better than anyone: eradicating poverty through entrepreneurship. Until then, the Chinese will parry any frantic moves to discredit them, and patiently wait for the endgame.

Michael Fairbanks went to Africa as a U.S. Peace Corps teacher in 1979. He is the author of "In The River They Swim". (www.sevenfund.org)




Links to Related Topics (Tags):

Headlines: March, 2010; Peace Corps Kenya; Directory of Kenya RPCVs; Messages and Announcements for Kenya RPCVs; NGO's; Speaking Out





When this story was posted in March 2010, this was on the front page of PCOL:




Peace Corps Online The Independent News Forum serving Returned Peace Corps Volunteers RSS Feed

 Site Index Search PCOL with Google Contact PCOL Recent Posts Bulletin Board Open Discussion RPCV Directory Register

Feb 10, 2010: Senator Dodd to Retire Date: February 19 2010 No: 1433 Feb 10, 2010: Senator Dodd to Retire
Dodd retires from Senate 6 Jan
Cameron Hume named US Ambassador to Pakistan 8 Feb
Florida RPCVs sponsor Everglades Experience 6 Feb
Jeff Hall brings aid to Sierra Leone 1 Feb
Peace Corps to reach 11,000 PCVs in 2016 1 Feb
Hugh Pickens writes: Standing Bear Looks to the Future 27 Jan
Ann Varghese survives 55 hours in Haiti rubble 26 Jan
John Guy LaPlante at 80 was oldest PCV 17 Jan
Steve Radelet to advise Hilary Clinton on Development 15 Jan
Obituary for Co-Author of ‘The Ugly American' 14 Jan
Peace Corps Establishes Program in Indonesia 11 Dec
What Happened to Obama's Promise? 3 Dec
George Packer writes: Obama's Troubles 24 Nov
PC Mourns Loss of Morocco PCV So-Youn Kim 17 Nov
Peace Corps volunteers return to Madagascar 16 Nov
PC to grow by several thousand over next 2 years 15 Nov
Former Hostage John Limbert named to Iran Bureau 11 Nov
Carrie Hessler Radelet named PC Deputy Director 9 Nov
Garamendi Sworn into Congress 9 Nov
Jesse Lonergan writes graphic novel "Joe and Azat" 4 Nov
David Macaray writes: Hearts and Minds in Afghanistan 29 Oct
Dustin Hogenson writes: Sauna in Kazakstan 26 Oct


Memo to Incoming Director Williams Date: August 24 2009 No: 1419 Memo to Incoming Director Williams
PCOL has asked five prominent RPCVs and Staff to write a memo on the most important issues facing the Peace Corps today. Issues raised include the independence of the Peace Corps, political appointments at the agency, revitalizing the five-year rule, lowering the ET rate, empowering volunteers, removing financial barriers to service, increasing the agency's budget, reducing costs, and making the Peace Corps bureaucracy more efficient and responsive. Latest: Greetings from Director Williams

Join Us Mr. President! Date: June 26 2009 No: 1380 Join Us Mr. President!
"We will double the size of the Peace Corps by its 50th anniversary in 2011. And we'll reach out to other nations to engage their young people in similar programs, so that we work side by side to take on the common challenges that confront all humanity," said Barack Obama during his campaign. Returned Volunteers rally and and march to the White House to support a bold new Peace Corps for a new age. Latest: Senator Dodd introduces Peace Corps Improvement and Expansion Act of 2009 .

Meet Aaron Williams - Our Next Director Date: July 30 2009 No: 1411 Meet Aaron Williams - Our Next Director
Senator Dodd's Senate Subcommittee held confirmation hearings for Aaron Williams to become the 18th Peace Corps Director. "It's exciting to have a nominee who served in the Peace Corps and also has experience in international development and management," said Dodd as he put Williams on the fast track to be confirmed by the full Senate before the August recess. Read our exclusive coverage of the hearings and our biography of Peace Corps Director Aaron Williams.



Read the stories and leave your comments.








Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.

Story Source: Huffington Post

This story has been posted in the following forums: : Headlines; COS - Kenya; NGOs; Speaking Out

PCOL45439
78


Add a Message


This is a public posting area. Enter your username and password if you have an account. Otherwise, enter your full name as your username and leave the password blank. Your e-mail address is optional.
Username:  
Password:
E-mail: