2011.02.10: February 10, 2011: For Ex-Hostage Bruce Rosen, Lawsuit Against Iran Is Unfinished Business
Peace Corps Online:
Directory:
Iran:
Peace Corps Iran :
Peace Corps Iran: Newest Stories:
2011.02.10: February 10, 2011: For Ex-Hostage Bruce Rosen, Lawsuit Against Iran Is Unfinished Business
For Ex-Hostage Bruce Rosen, Lawsuit Against Iran Is Unfinished Business
There is unfinished business for the former hostages. Forty of the 52 are living. For years, they have sought justice in the form of compensation from Iran for their suffering. But a lawsuit on their behalf has gone nowhere in American courts. The main obstacle is an agreement between the United States and Iran known as the Algiers Accords, reached the day before the hostages were freed. In return for their release, Washington pledged to unfreeze Iranian assets that had been seized after the hostage-taking and to give Iran immunity from lawsuits like the one being pursued. Through six presidencies, Republican and Democratic alike, the government's position has been that the accords form an enduring obligation, unshaken by Congressional attempts to override it with antiterrorism legislation that effectively endorsed the former hostages' right to sue Iran. The federal courts have thus far sided with the government, though appellate judges in Washington will take up the case this year. From the hostages' vantage, the Algiers Accords were reached with a gun pointed at America's head. "It's very clear from communiqués at the time that the Iranians were going to try, convict and hang these folks," said their lawyer, V. Thomas Lankford Jr., of Alexandria, Va. To him and his clients, the accords amounted to "a ransom note." About 150 Americans are part of the lawsuit, including surviving hostages, the estates of those who died and some relatives. In all, they are seeking $6.6 billion in damages, but no one pretends that is a realistic figure. The true purpose of a big number like that, Mr. Lankford said, is to take a firm stand against state-sponsored terrorism, by "making it costly enough to where you just don't go out and do it."
For Ex-Hostage Bruce Rosen, Lawsuit Against Iran Is Unfinished Business
For Ex-Hostage, Lawsuit Against Iran Is Unfinished Business
By CLYDE HABERMAN
Published: February 10, 2011
Barry Rosen's fascination with Iran began in 1967, when he went there from his native Brooklyn for a two-year adventure as a Peace Corps volunteer. He taught English and he learned Farsi, the Persian spoken by Iranians. "Iran became, in many ways, a second home for me," he said the other day.
A decade later, that home turned hostile.
Mr. Rosen was back in Tehran, this time as the press attaché at the United States Embassy. On Nov. 4, 1979, he became one of 52 Americans who would be taken prisoner for 444 days by militants angry after the deposed Shah of Iran was allowed into the United States for medical treatment.
Some of the American hostages were beaten. Some were subject to mock executions. "We were the first victims of modern state-sponsored terrorism," Mr. Rosen said.
The crisis ended on Jan. 20, 1981, as Jimmy Carter's presidency yielded to Ronald Reagan's. Minutes after Mr. Reagan was sworn in, Iran let its captives go. They returned home a few days later, embraced by family and by a relieved nation that felt as if it, too, had been held hostage.
Those distant events resonate now with the Egyptian uprising and questions about whether it could become a reprise of the 1979 Islamic revolution in Iran, which replaced the Shah's dictatorship with a repressive theocracy.
There is also unfinished business for the former hostages. Forty of the 52 are living. For years, they have sought justice in the form of compensation from Iran for their suffering. But a lawsuit on their behalf has gone nowhere in American courts.
The main obstacle is an agreement between the United States and Iran known as the Algiers Accords, reached the day before the hostages were freed. In return for their release, Washington pledged to unfreeze Iranian assets that had been seized after the hostage-taking and to give Iran immunity from lawsuits like the one being pursued.
Through six presidencies, Republican and Democratic alike, the government's position has been that the accords form an enduring obligation, unshaken by Congressional attempts to override it with antiterrorism legislation that effectively endorsed the former hostages' right to sue Iran. The federal courts have thus far sided with the government, though appellate judges in Washington will take up the case this year.
From the hostages' vantage, the Algiers Accords were reached with a gun pointed at America's head. "It's very clear from communiqués at the time that the Iranians were going to try, convict and hang these folks," said their lawyer, V. Thomas Lankford Jr., of Alexandria, Va. To him and his clients, the accords amounted to "a ransom note."
About 150 Americans are part of the lawsuit, including surviving hostages, the estates of those who died and some relatives. In all, they are seeking $6.6 billion in damages, but no one pretends that is a realistic figure. The true purpose of a big number like that, Mr. Lankford said, is to take a firm stand against state-sponsored terrorism, by "making it costly enough to where you just don't go out and do it."
That is also the view of Mr. Rosen, the lone New Yorker in the group. "Iranians need to know that you just can't do this in this world," he said, "abrogating international law, walking into an embassy, taking over people. They really didn't learn a lesson from the hostage crisis."
It galls him that the State and Justice Departments have consistently opposed the hostages in court. It is, he said, almost as if "the Iranian government and the American government are somehow in collaboration on this issue."
A few weeks ago, on the 30th anniversary of their being freed, about 20 of the surviving hostages held a reunion at West Point, where they were first taken after returning to American soil. It was a happy gathering, Mr. Rosen said, but there was also despair about the lawsuit - "a certain sense that nothing will come of it."
Obviously, none of them are getting younger. Mr. Rosen is 66, a grandfather of four. After Iran, he settled into a relatively sedate life. These days, he is in charge of public and external affairs at the Borough of Manhattan Community College.
But his spirit of adventure did not die. Eight years ago, he went to Afghanistan, part of an international team trying to rebuild that country's educational system. The principal language of people he worked with was Dari, a close cousin of the Farsi that he spoke. "Ironically," the former hostage said, "they used to call me ‘Mr. Iranian.' "
E-mail: haberman@nytimes.com
Links to Related Topics (Tags):
Headlines: February, 2011; Peace Corps Iran; Directory of Iran RPCVs; Messages and Announcements for Iran RPCVs
When this story was posted in February 2011, this was on the front page of PCOL:
Peace Corps Online The Independent News Forum serving Returned Peace Corps Volunteers
| How Volunteers Remember Sarge As the Peace Corps' Founding Director Sargent Shriver laid the foundations for the most lasting accomplishment of the Kennedy presidency. Shriver spoke to returned volunteers at the Peace Vigil at Lincoln Memorial in September, 2001 for the Peace Corps 40th. "The challenge I believe is simple - simple to express but difficult to fulfill. That challenge is expressed in these words: PCV's - stay as you are. Be servants of peace. Work at home as you have worked abroad. Humbly, persistently, intelligently. Weep with those who are sorrowful, Care for those who are sick. Serve your wives, serve your husbands, serve your families, serve your neighbors, serve your cities, serve the poor, join others who also serve," said Shriver. "Serve, Serve, Serve. That's the answer, that's the objective, that's the challenge." |
| Support Independent Funding for the Third Goal The Peace Corps has always neglected the third goal, allocating less than 1% of their resources to "bringing the world back home." Senator Dodd addressed this issue in the "Peace Corps for the 21st Century" bill passed by the US Senate and Peace Corps Director Ron Tschetter proposed a "Peace Corps Foundation" at no cost to the US government. Both are good approaches but the recent "Comprehensive Assessment Report" didn't address the issue of independent funding for the third goal at all. |
| Memo to Incoming Director Williams PCOL has asked five prominent RPCVs and Staff to write a memo on the most important issues facing the Peace Corps today. Issues raised include the independence of the Peace Corps, political appointments at the agency, revitalizing the five-year rule, lowering the ET rate, empowering volunteers, removing financial barriers to service, increasing the agency's budget, reducing costs, and making the Peace Corps bureaucracy more efficient and responsive. Latest: Greetings from Director Williams |
Read the stories and leave your comments.
Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.
Story Source: NY Times
This story has been posted in the following forums: : Headlines; COS - Iran; Hostages
PCOL46658
30