2008.02.12: February 12, 2008: Headlines: Criticism: Michigan Daily: Paul H. Johnson at the University of Michigan writes: What counts as useful criticism of the Peace Corps?

Peace Corps Online: Peace Corps News: Peace Corps Library: Criticism of the Peace Corps: January 23, 2005: Index: PCOL Exclusive: Criticism: 2008.01.29: January 29, 2008: Headlines: Criticism: Michigan Daily: Some students at University of Michigan question the motivations of Peace Corps participants and their reasoning for joining the program : 2008.02.12: February 12, 2008: Headlines: Criticism: Michigan Daily: Paul H. Johnson at the University of Michigan writes: What counts as useful criticism of the Peace Corps?

By Admin1 (admin) (pool-141-157-69-110.balt.east.verizon.net - 141.157.69.110) on Wednesday, February 13, 2008 - 11:54 am: Edit Post

Paul H. Johnson at the University of Michigan writes: What counts as useful criticism of the Peace Corps?

Paul H. Johnson at the University of Michigan writes: What counts as useful criticism of the Peace Corps?

Even the first director of the Peace Corps, Sargent Shriver, said that the Peace Corps shows Americans that our good will isn't always welcome. He said: "Peace Corps Volunteers come home to the USA realizing that there are billions-yes, billions-of human beings not enraptured by our pretensions, or our practices, or even our standards of conduct." As Sen. Christopher Dodd (D-Conn.) said in a speech during the 45th anniversary of the Peace Corps criticism is something that the organization embraces. Dodd said: "The Peace Corps is one sustained exercise in self-criticism, and that's just its strength. For our young men and women, living and serving among poverty is an implicit censure of their relative wealth. Learning to serve and work with our hands is a self-criticism, because it confronts us with our weaknesses."

Paul H. Johnson at the University of Michigan writes: What counts as useful criticism of the Peace Corps?

Paul H. Johnson: What counts as useful criticism?

By Paul H. Johnson on 2/12/08


Thousands of Americans, particularly from the University of Michigan, have traveled the world thanks to the Peace Corps. So it comes as no surprise that there was a vigorous reader response to an article that raised questions about the motivations of the Peace Corps (University ranks fifth in grads joining Peace Corps, 01/29/2008). The article questioned whether Peace Corps volunteers were choosing to go abroad for the right reasons. Readers worried that the article unfairly maligned the Peace Corps and that the article's criticisms weren't carefully considered.

Basically, I think the Daily could have done more reporting. The article extensively quoted an LSA senior Claudia Williams who raised many of the questions about the Peace Corps, but the Daily never explained to readers why this particular person was talking about the Peace Corps or what her motivation was for talking. While I think she has the right to her point of view, the Daily should have also found more critics to talk about shortcomings that may exist in the Peace Corps. Also, the article could have fleshed out why this particular senior was talking about the program. There have been a number of studies conducted about the Peace Corps and it's value or lack thereof.

Daily staff Reporter Gabe Rivin, an LSA senior, said he found Williams by walking through Mason Hall and talking to people about their opinion of the program. Rivin said that the woman told him she was from a developing country and had first-hand experience about the Peace Corps, but she didn't name the country. That fact got edited out of the story.

Knowing more about Williams would have given her criticisms more weight and added to the value of her comments. But the article did allow the speakers to respond to the criticisms leveled. As well, Rivin said he was pressed for time in completing the article. He said the Daily should consider giving more time for articles that aren't particularly time sensitive, like this one. This would make sure the reporting could be fleshed out more completely.

The criticisms of the Peace Corps expressed in the article have been mentioned for years in one form or another.

Some of the criticisms have been rather comical. The late Sen. Jesse Helms (R-N.C.) once told The New York Times that he saw funding for the Peace Corps as "more ratfood for the Third World" and called the organization a refuge "for drugged-out losers, leftists and homosexuals." Even the first director of the Peace Corps, Sargent Shriver, said that the Peace Corps shows Americans that our good will isn't always welcome. He said: "Peace Corps Volunteers come home to the USA realizing that there are billions-yes, billions-of human beings not enraptured by our pretensions, or our practices, or even our standards of conduct."

As Sen. Christopher Dodd (D-Conn.) said in a speech during the 45th anniversary of the Peace Corps criticism is something that the organization embraces. Dodd said: "The Peace Corps is one sustained exercise in self-criticism, and that's just its strength. For our young men and women, living and serving among poverty is an implicit censure of their relative wealth. Learning to serve and work with our hands is a self-criticism, because it confronts us with our weaknesses."

So it's worth talking about the Peace Corps and I think the letters published in the Daily in response had well-crafted objections to the article.

On the flip side is yesterday's story about Teach for America ('U' leads nation in Teach for America applicants, 02/11/2008), which could have used a similar touch. But, in that story, there were not any criticisms leveled against the program. I think any organization that does good would be served well by airing and responding to the criticisms leveled against its mission.

The Daily can't be afraid to go after institutions, even ones as revered as the Peace Corps and Teach for America, so readers can have all the information available about these programs that affect so many lives.

Paul H. Johnson is the Daily's public editor. He can be reached at publiceditor@umich.edu.




Links to Related Topics (Tags):

Headlines: February, 2008; Criticism; Michigan





When this story was posted in February 2008, this was on the front page of PCOL:


Contact PCOLBulletin BoardRegisterSearch PCOLWhat's New?

Peace Corps Online The Independent News Forum serving Returned Peace Corps Volunteers RSS Feed
Dodd vows to filibuster Surveillance Act Date: October 27 2007 No: 1206 Dodd vows to filibuster Surveillance Act
Senator Chris Dodd vowed to filibuster the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act that would grant retroactive immunity to telecommunications companies that helped this administration violate the civil liberties of Americans. "It is time to say: No more. No more trampling on our Constitution. No more excusing those who violate the rule of law. These are fundamental, basic, eternal principles. They have been around, some of them, for as long as the Magna Carta. They are enduring. What they are not is temporary. And what we do not do in a time where our country is at risk is abandon them."

Peace Corps News Peace Corps Library Peace corps History RPCV Directory Sign Up

January 12, 2008: This Month's Top Stories Date: January 13 2008 No: 1221 January 12, 2008: This Month's Top Stories
Jack Vaughn, Peace Corps Legend 12 Jan
Hill Puts Gentle Pressure on North Korea 11 Jan
Sarah Chayes writes Bhutto's decision tarnishes her memory 10 Jan
Tom Petri is a Republican who 'gets it' 10 Jan
Robert Strauss writes: PCVs lack maturity and experience 9 Jan
James Rupert writes: Musharraf May Use Election Delay 7 Jan
Senate Increases Funding for Peace Corps 4 Jan
Chris Dodd addresses supporters after Iowa Caucuses 3 Jan
John Granville Shot Dead in Sudan 2 Jan
Kathleen Stephens appointed ambassador to South Korea 19 Dec
Obituary for St. Clair Bourne 18 Dec
Dr. Robert Zeigler warns of global rice shortage 13 Dec
PCV Blythe Ann O’Sullivan dies in Suriname accident 8 Dec
David Kotz named new Inspector General at SEC 6 Dec
Obama calls for doubling the size of the Peace Corps 5 Dec
Obituary for Henry Hyde - Friend of the Peace Corps 29 Nov
Robert M. Gates calls for “soft power” tools 27 Nov
Kevin Quigley writes: To win the peace, Restore the corps 27 Nov
Michael Adlerstein says UN renovation will be done right 27 Nov
Peru Trade Pact is Victory for Toledo 24 Nov
Crisis Corps is now Peace Corps Response 19 Nov
Tony Hall works for Middle East peace 13 Nov

Peace Corps Volunteers Remain Safe in Kenya Date: January 5 2008 No: 1218 Peace Corps Volunteers Remain Safe in Kenya
The U.S. Peace Corps has evacuated 35 of its volunteers from western Kenya because of the violence that has rocked the country since the disputed December 27 presidential election. The Peace Corps has 144 volunteers based in Kenya, although the organization says 22 of them are currently out of the country. An agency statement says the remaining volunteers have been consolidated in a variety of locations. Latest News: Peace Corps says volunteers in Kenya remain safe.

What is the greatest threat facing us now?  Date: September 12 2007 No: 1195 What is the greatest threat facing us now?
"People will say it's terrorism. But are there any terrorists in the world who can change the American way of life or our political system? No. Can they knock down a building? Yes. Can they kill somebody? Yes. But can they change us? No. Only we can change ourselves. So what is the great threat we are facing? I would approach this differently, in almost Marshall-like terms. What are the great opportunities out there - ones that we can take advantage of?" Read more.



Read the stories and leave your comments.








Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.

Story Source: Michigan Daily

This story has been posted in the following forums: : Headlines; Criticism

PCOL40512
23


Add a Message


This is a public posting area. Enter your username and password if you have an account. Otherwise, enter your full name as your username and leave the password blank. Your e-mail address is optional.
Username:  
Password:
E-mail: