2009.01.29: January 29, 2009: Headlines: COS - Afghanistan: Politics: Speaking Out: Michigan Live: RPCV Charles Stroh writes: Afghanistan may need a change in government to make addition of 30,000 U.S. troops worthwhile

Peace Corps Online: Directory: Afghanistan: Peace Corps Afghanistan: Peace Corps Afghanistan: Newest Stories: 2009.01.29: January 29, 2009: Headlines: COS - Afghanistan: Politics: Speaking Out: Michigan Live: RPCV Charles Stroh writes: Afghanistan may need a change in government to make addition of 30,000 U.S. troops worthwhile

By Admin1 (admin) (151.196.123.89) on Monday, February 16, 2009 - 6:14 pm: Edit Post

RPCV Charles Stroh writes: Afghanistan may need a change in government to make addition of 30,000 U.S. troops worthwhile

RPCV Charles Stroh writes: Afghanistan may need a change in government to make addition of 30,000 U.S. troops worthwhile

Increasingly, Karzai is being seen as an impediment to change rather than a facilitator. He has not been effective in overseeing many things that are central to solving the various indigenous problems such as drugs, smuggling, corruption and nepotism. Many, including the current U.S. administration, NATO, and other leaders in Afghanistan are beginning to call for a change in government. General David Petraeus seems to see the large picture and he, along with others in the region realize the necessity of bringing together Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iran, Russia and China to find a reasonable solution to these intractable problems. It is one of the encouraging initiatives coming from that difficult place these days. It is encouraging that President Obama met with General Petraeus on his first or second day in office and it will be a welcome sign if one of President Obama's early actions is to respond to these calls for regional cooperation.

RPCV Charles Stroh writes: Afghanistan may need a change in government to make addition of 30,000 U.S. troops worthwhile

Afghanistan may need a change in government to make addition of 30,000 U.S. troops worthwhile

Posted by Charles Stroh

January 29, 2009 12:56PM

In a Jan. 18 Washington Post column, NATO Secretary-General Jaap de Hoop Scheffer wrote, "The basic problem in Afghanistan is not too much Taliban; it's too little good governance. We have paid enough, in blood and treasure, to demand that the Afghan government take more concrete and vigorous action to root out corruption and increase efficiency, even where that means difficult political choices."

The United States has plans to add 30,000 additional troops to the 32,000 that we currently have there and President Barack Obama has already suggested that he agrees with that action. De Hoop Scheffer agrees that extra forces are necessary to avoid a "stalemate situation" that is becoming the new reality.

NATO and U.S. forces have already trained nearly 100,000 Afghan soldiers and police and most critics of the current government say that these forces should begin to take over greater responsibilities. But, there is unanimous agreement that these soldiers and police forces are incapable of doing what is expected of them. They are accused of substantial corruption and that is likely correct.

But, it must be remembered that only a tiny fraction of the money we send to Afghanistan ever gets to Afghans. Nearly 75 percent of every dollar goes to pay Americans and other foreigners in Afghanistan. Very little benefits the average Afghan.

The newly trained Afghan forces are drawn largely from northern, central, and western Afghanistan and not from the south and east. Among other things, this means that they might have some modicum of authority in their own ethnic areas, but little to none in Pashtun areas of the south and east. It also means that they would have little effect in Pakistan where it is the Pashtun tribal areas that are at the core of the problems between Pakistan and Afghanistan.

Historically, a national army in Afghanistan has never been effective. Successes in the past in driving out foreign invaders has come from allegiances of tribal groups that ebb and flow according to local need. That situation has not changed with the people we have trained. Simply stated, the soldiers and police cannot be trusted to act in the national interest without direct supervision by international forces.

It may be true that with additional international forces, that this local militia can be convinced to act against their personal interest and in favor of national interest, but it will not happen in one or even two generations. And, without such a national force, any president of Afghanistan cannot be effective in the tribal areas. Like it is with President Karzai, who is effectively only the President of Kabul, life in the provinces will go on without much change.

Increasingly, Karzai is being seen as an impediment to change rather than a facilitator. He has not been effective in overseeing many things that are central to solving the various indigenous problems such as drugs, smuggling, corruption and nepotism. Many, including the current U.S. administration, NATO, and other leaders in Afghanistan are beginning to call for a change in government.

General David Petraeus seems to see the large picture and he, along with others in the region realize the necessity of bringing together Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iran, Russia and China to find a reasonable solution to these intractable problems. It is one of the encouraging initiatives coming from that difficult place these days.

It is encouraging that President Obama met with General Petraeus on his first or second day in office and it will be a welcome sign if one of President Obama's early actions is to respond to these calls for regional cooperation.

Charles Stroh is a retired professor from Western Michigan University and was a Peace Corps Volunteer in Afghanistan from 1969-1971. He follows the news from that country on a daily list serve, the Afghan Online Press.




Links to Related Topics (Tags):

Headlines: January, 2009; Peace Corps Afghanistan; Directory of Afghanistan RPCVs; Messages and Announcements for Afghanistan RPCVs; Politics; Speaking Out





When this story was posted in February 2009, this was on the front page of PCOL:




Peace Corps Online The Independent News Forum serving Returned Peace Corps Volunteers RSS Feed

 Site Index Search PCOL with Google Contact PCOL Recent Posts Bulletin Board Open Discussion RPCV Directory Register

PCOL's Candidate for Peace Corps Director Date: December 2 2008 No: 1288 PCOL's Candidate for Peace Corps Director
Honduras RPCV Jon Carson, 33, presided over thousands of workers as national field director for the Obama campaign and said the biggest challenge -- and surprise -- was the volume of volunteer help, including more than 15,000 "super volunteers," who were a big part of what made Obama's campaign so successful. PCOL endorses Jon Carson as the man who can revitalize the Peace Corps, bring it into the internet age, and meet Obama's goal of doubling the size of the Peace Corps by 2011.

Director Ron Tschetter:  The PCOL Interview Date: December 9 2008 No: 1296 Director Ron Tschetter: The PCOL Interview
Peace Corps Director Ron Tschetter sat down for an in-depth interview to discuss the evacuation from Bolivia, political appointees at Peace Corps headquarters, the five year rule, the Peace Corps Foundation, the internet and the Peace Corps, how the transition is going, and what the prospects are for doubling the size of the Peace Corps by 2011. Read the interview and you are sure to learn something new about the Peace Corps. PCOL previously did an interview with Director Gaddi Vasquez.

Jan 24, 2009: RPCVs March in Inauguration Date: January 25 2009 No: 1309 Jan 24, 2009: RPCVs March in Inauguration
Peace Corps Community marches in Inaugural Parade 20 Jan
Jane Albritton writes: Memories of Maury Albertson 18 Jan
Sarah Chayes writes: Failing Afghanistan 15 Dec
Volunteers in Guinea are Safe 23 Dec
Jim Walsh reflects on 20 years of service 28 Dec
Public service in Driehaus' blood 3 Jan
An Interview with Kathleen Stephens 3 Jan
Robert P. Cristo returns to Nigeria 4 Jan
Sarah Holt makes 2,663-mile hike along the Pacific Crest Trail 5 Jan
Zophia Kneiss is metal sculptor 11 Jan
Harris Wofford is Godfather of National Service 12 Jan
Melanie Edwards founds Mobile Metrix 14 Jan
Jody Olsen Named PC Acting Director 16 Jan
Lawrence Leamer writes: Obama betrays the Peace Corps? 18 Jan
George Packer writes: Obama's Inaugural Address 20 Jan
Obama going to do something great for Peace Corps 21 Jan
John Bridgeland writes: Volunteer to Save the Economy 22 Jan
Foy Spicer writes: Electricity as a scarcity 23 Jan
Carl Pope to Step Down as Sierra Club Chief 23 Jan
James Rupert writes: US Missile Attacks Kill 15 24 Jan
Jeffrey Tayler writes "Murderers in Mausoleums" 25 Jan
Read more stories from January 2009 and December 2008.

Some PCVs return to Bolivia on their own Date: October 23 2008 No: 1279 Some PCVs return to Bolivia on their own
Peace Corps has withdrawn all volunteers from Bolivia because of "growing instability" and the expulsion of US Ambassador Philip Goldberg after Bolivian President Evo Morales accused the American government of inciting violence in the country. This is not the first controversy surrounding Goldberg's tenure as US ambassador to Bolivia. Latest: Some volunteers have returned to Bolivia on their own to complete their projects.

PCVs Evacuated from Georgia Date: August 19 2008 No: 1254 PCVs Evacuated from Georgia
The Peace Corps has announced that all Volunteers and trainees serving in the Republic of Georgia are safe and they have been temporarily relocated to neighboring Armenia. Read the analysis by one RPCV on how Georgia's President Mikheil Saakashvili believed that he could launch a lightning assault on South Ossetia and reclaim the republic without substantial grief from Moscow and that Saakashvili's statements once the war began demonstrated that he expected real Western help in confronting Russia.



Read the stories and leave your comments.








Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.

Story Source: Michigan Live

This story has been posted in the following forums: : Headlines; COS - Afghanistan; Politics; Speaking Out

PCOL42846
24


Add a Message


This is a public posting area. Enter your username and password if you have an account. Otherwise, enter your full name as your username and leave the password blank. Your e-mail address is optional.
Username:  
Password:
E-mail: