2008.07.27: July 27, 2008: Headlines: COS - Korea: COS - China: Figures: COS - Cameroon: Diplomacy: Newsweek: How diplomats like Christopher Hill used back channels to overcome White House reluctance to negotiate with Pyongyang

Peace Corps Online: Directory: Cameroon: RPCV Christopher R. Hill (Cameroon) : RPCV Christopher R. Hill: Newest Stories: 2008.07.27: July 27, 2008: Headlines: COS - Korea: COS - China: Figures: COS - Cameroon: Diplomacy: Newsweek: How diplomats like Christopher Hill used back channels to overcome White House reluctance to negotiate with Pyongyang

By Admin1 (admin) (75.40.135.121) on Wednesday, August 06, 2008 - 7:24 am: Edit Post

How diplomats like Christopher Hill used back channels to overcome White House reluctance to negotiate with Pyongyang

How diplomats like Christopher Hill used back channels to overcome White House reluctance to negotiate with Pyongyang

Hill is a protégé of Richard Holbrooke, the famously tenacious career diplomat who was himself influenced by Henry Kissinger, the legendary realist and White House operator. In the spirit of these mentors, Hill plowed over anyone who stood between him and the president's wishes. In May 2007, when North Korea protested a Treasury Department move to freeze some $25 million in allegedly illicit funds it held offshore, Hill led an effort to find a bank that would transfer the money back to Pyongyang. "We are not going to allow $25 million ... to get between us and a deal," Hill told the Korea Society at the time. A participant at a meeting of U.S. government officials involved in the dispute said he was startled by the pungent language Hill employed when discussing his Treasury counterparts in meetings with European government officials. "Hill is a forceful negotiator, and this deal will be as much his legacy as Bush's," said the participant, who did not want to be quoted recounting a closed-door session. "But he can be abrasive and he's not necessarily a team player." Still, on that occasion Hill needed Rice's help to break the stalemate. She persuaded U.S. Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson that the embargo on Pyongyang's overseas accounts had taught it a lesson—Washington could cut off North Korea's funds at will—and that lifting the embargo would offer the Kim Jong Il regime a face-saving way to return to the negotiating table. Christopher R. Hill, assistant secretary of state for East Asian and Pacific Affairs and former U.S. ambassador to South Korea, served as a Peace Corps Volunteer in Cameroon.

How diplomats like Christopher Hill used back channels to overcome White House reluctance to negotiate with Pyongyang

Anatomy of a Nuclear Deal

How diplomats used back channels to overcome White House reluctance to negotiate with Pyongyang.

By Stephen Glain | Newsweek Web Exclusive

Jul 27, 2008 | Updated: 10:43 a.m. ET Jul 26, 2008

Historians may one day call it the "duty-free demarche." In December 2006, U.S. arms negotiator Victor Cha was departing Beijing after another failed round of talks on North Korea's nukes. While waiting in the baggage line, Cha suddenly found himself standing next to Kim Gwe Gwan, Pyongyang's lead negotiator. The two men chatted amiably for a few minutes and then Kim suggested they meet at the duty-free shop after Cha passed through security. Once there, standing between the cigarette and liquor counters, Kim told Cha that Pyongyang favored direct Korean-American talks in the hope this would revive the moribund negotiations.
Back in Washington, Cha delivered Kim's back-channel appeal to his boss, national-security adviser Stephen Hadley, who requested a memo on how the White House should proceed. Cha drafted an 850-word argument in favor of holding a single round of direct talks. The memo was passed up to the Oval Office and within weeks President George W. Bush reversed one of his bedrock policies: never negotiate directly with rogue states. What then followed was a 16-month diplomatic onslaught of a sort completely foreign to the go-it-alone Bush presidency.

"We decided to give this a try as a last option," says Cha, who has returned to a teaching post at Georgetown since leaving the NSC last May. "If it failed, it may have well meant the death of the negotiations." Having decided it was going to make a serious push to resolve the North Korean nuclear issue, the next job became revising the dysfunctional American bureaucratic approach to the negotiations. For much of Bush's second term, the U.S. process had been confused and haphazard. Diplomats like Christopher Hill, tasked by Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice to lead the U.S. efforts, had been routinely pre-empted by White House hard-liners, particularly from Vice President Dick Cheney's office. That only changed once Bush himself endorsed the Cha memo, according to a former White House official who did not want to be quoted discussing interagency rivalries. "Once Hill was given the green light from Bush, his path opened up," says the ex-official. "At senior-level meetings, when someone would protest Hill's initiatives, Hadley would declare 'this is what the president and Rice want to try,' and that would settle it."

To help cage Cheney's hawks, it helped that Rice had a Rottweiler on her side. Hill is a protégé of Richard Holbrooke, the famously tenacious career diplomat who was himself influenced by Henry Kissinger, the legendary realist and White House operator. In the spirit of these mentors, Hill plowed over anyone who stood between him and the president's wishes. In May 2007, when North Korea protested a Treasury Department move to freeze some $25 million in allegedly illicit funds it held offshore, Hill led an effort to find a bank that would transfer the money back to Pyongyang. "We are not going to allow $25 million ... to get between us and a deal," Hill told the Korea Society at the time. A participant at a meeting of U.S. government officials involved in the dispute said he was startled by the pungent language Hill employed when discussing his Treasury counterparts in meetings with European government officials. "Hill is a forceful negotiator, and this deal will be as much his legacy as Bush's," said the participant, who did not want to be quoted recounting a closed-door session. "But he can be abrasive and he's not necessarily a team player." Still, on that occasion Hill needed Rice's help to break the stalemate. She persuaded U.S. Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson that the embargo on Pyongyang's overseas accounts had taught it a lesson—Washington could cut off North Korea's funds at will—and that lifting the embargo would offer the Kim Jong Il regime a face-saving way to return to the negotiating table.

Hill offset his abrasiveness with an inexhaustible zest for shuttle diplomacy and a canny ability to use the media. Whether stopping over in Beijing, Seoul or Tokyo, he always made time for press briefings and ensured correspondents were text-messaged the latest changes in his itinerary. In March, Hill met with North Korean negotiators to hammer out a framework for a deal. The two sides agreed to a compromise: in exchange for an acknowledgment from Pyongyang of U.S. concerns about its suspected uranium supplies and its alleged sharing of nuclear technology with Syria, the United States agreed to focus only on North Korea's known plutonium stocks as a first step in the eventual dismantling of its nuclear program. A month later, when the two sides met again in Singapore, Hill told reporters that there had been "a considerable narrowing of views." (His remarks earned him a rebuke from Rice, who had imposed an embargo on official statements at the time, according to several officials involved in the negotiations.)

On June 26, Bush announced the agreement in the White House Rose Garden. Conservatives condemned the deal as appeasement. Yet Bush's embrace of the Cha memo shows that even a reluctant diplomatist can treat with enemies constructively if the resources and authority of the presidency are fully invested in the process. Hill's efforts show how much a hard-nosed negotiator, when backed up by a strong patron like Rice, can achieve even with a bitter antagonist like North Korea. We've come a long way. In 1994, in response to U.S. and South Korean saber-rattling over its arsenal, Pyongyang threatened to turn Seoul into a "sea of fire." Today, Sung Kim, Hill's No. 2 at the State Department and a Korean-America, regularly shuttles from Washington to Pyongyang, where he's established workmanlike relations with his North Korean counterparts. Hawks may blast Bush for flip-flopping—John Bolton, his former U.N. ambassador, has referred to the administration's shift as a "moral collapse"—but the president deserves credit for choosing to "jaw-jaw" with Pyongyang instead of "war-war," to paraphrase Winston Churchill. The question now is whether Bush will show a similar realism toward Iran, and whether there's enough time left in his administration to make progress on that front.




Links to Related Topics (Tags):

Headlines: July, 2008; RPCV Christopher Hill (Cameroon); Peace Corps Korea; Directory of Korea RPCVs; Messages and Announcements for Korea RPCVs; Peace Corps China; Directory of China RPCVs; Messages and Announcements for China RPCVs; Figures; Peace Corps Cameroon; Directory of Cameroon RPCVs; Messages and Announcements for Cameroon RPCVs; Diplomacy; Rhode Island





When this story was posted in August 2008, this was on the front page of PCOL:


Contact PCOLBulletin BoardRegisterSearch PCOLWhat's New?

Peace Corps Online The Independent News Forum serving Returned Peace Corps Volunteers RSS Feed
Dodd vows to filibuster Surveillance Act Date: October 27 2007 No: 1206 Dodd vows to filibuster Surveillance Act
Senator Chris Dodd vowed to filibuster the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act that would grant retroactive immunity to telecommunications companies that helped this administration violate the civil liberties of Americans. "It is time to say: No more. No more trampling on our Constitution. No more excusing those who violate the rule of law. These are fundamental, basic, eternal principles. They have been around, some of them, for as long as the Magna Carta. They are enduring. What they are not is temporary. And what we do not do in a time where our country is at risk is abandon them."

Peace Corps News Peace Corps Library Peace corps History RPCV Directory Sign Up

July 1, 2008: This Month's Top Stories Date: July 16 2008 No: 1245 July 1, 2008: This Month's Top Stories
Sarah Chayes continues work in Kandahar 29 Jun
PCV Catherine Saltwick killed in Automobile Accident 2 Jun
Richard Stoll returns to Tonga for capitol’s rebuild 2 Jun
Peace Corps Reopens Program in Liberia 4 Jun
Tu Dang is a Foreign Affairs Officer 4 Jun
Bethany Hedt takes aim at AIDS with statistics 5 Jun
Expanding opportunities for deaf PCVs 5 Jun
Peace Corps/Kenya Program Reopening 6 Jun
José Klein is plate artist 9 Jun
Kenyan Prime Minister Visits PC Headquarters 19 Jun
Michael Meyer's writes "The Last Days of Old Beijing" 20 Jun
Chuck Ludlam writes: Congress Enacts PCV Tax Law 24 Jun
Dodd Speaks in Opposition to FISA Bill 24 Jun
Christopher Hill critical to success in Korea Talks 25 Jun
Mark Gearan writes: Hillary Clinton's Contribution 25 Jun
James Rupert writes: Pakistan Fights Taliban 27 Jun
Elaine Chao hails U.S.-China dialogue 28 Jun
Obituary for Bud Keith - Champion for Disabled 29 Jun
Life in prison for killer of PCV Julia Campbell 30 Jun
John Coyne writes: PC Archives at JFK Library 30 Jun
Mark Shriver to Chair National Commission on Children 30 Jun

New: More Stories from May and June 2008
June 1, 2008: This Month's Top Stories Date: July 16 2008 No: 1247 June 1, 2008: This Month's Top Stories
Senator ties up Kathleen Stephens appointment 1 May
Philip Dacey writes "The New York Postcard Sonnets" 31 May
Sophia Polasky writes: Luncheon with the president 30 May
Arnold Wendroff warns dangers of ritual use of mercury 30 May
Lynn Lurie writes “Corner of the Dead" 29 May
Obama Urges Grads To Serve Country 26 May
Nick Mucha promotes development at surf destinations 25 May
Don Crosby and wife serve in Thailand at 70 23 May
Matthew Handley pursued case of 12 murdered Nepalis 22 May
Zig and Irma Sokolnicki receive President's Award 21 May
Bruce Sterling writes: Steve Cisler RIP 20 May
Colorado to host Peace Corps Reunion in August 19 May
Hugh Pickens writes: Death Be Not Proud 17 May
Zachery Scott writes: Being a gay volunteer 14 May
PCVs in China Are Safe after earthquake 12 May
Louis Adams relives PC days in Morocco 12 May
Jemison say US leaders have made foolish decisions 11 May
Amy Smith's low-tech inventions have high impact 8 May
Bill Moyers on the 2008 Elections 8 May
Don Odermann creates Education Fund for Latin Players 5 May
Peter Hessler wins National Magazine Award 2 May

New: More Stories from April and May 2008

May 1, 2008: This Month's Top Stories Date: May 2 2008 No: 1242 May 1, 2008: This Month's Top Stories
Condoleezza Rice Visits PC Headquarters 28 Apr
Bush hosts PCVs at White House 29 Apr
George Derrick is Oklahoma's first PCV 27 Apr
Debate is Brewing over Older Volunteers 25 Apr
Peter Spiro Scaled Corporate Ladder at Microsoft 24 Apr
Ukraine PCV terminated after testing HIV positive 22 Apr
Strauss writes: PC never lived up to purpose or principles 22 Apr
Atlantic Publishing needs your help on PC book 21 Apr
Nicole Nakama follows in footsteps of Father as PCV 21 Apr
Jerry LaPre writes: The Children of Sierra Leone 21 Apr
Robert Blackwill quits lobbying firm 19 Apr
An Interview with Christopher R. Hill 18 Apr
Harris Wofford introduces Obama's Speech on Race 18 Apr
Matthews could Challenge Arlen Specter for Senate 16 Apr
Lee Myung-bak invites 1500 RPCVs back to Korea 15 Apr
Peace Corps looks forward to returning to Kenya 11 Apr
Kathleen Stephens Quizzed by Congress 11 Apr
Campbell murder trial ends; Verdict set for June 30 9 Apr
Dodd Calls for New Strategic Partnership in Americas 9 Apr
Jake Hooker wins Pulitzer Prize for "A Toxic Pipeline" 9 Apr
Sirleaf welcomes return of PCVs to Liberia 8 Apr

New: More Stories from March and April 2008

What is Wrong at the US Embassy in Bolivia? Date: February 10 2008 No: 1227 What is Wrong at the US Embassy in Bolivia?
Last summer Peace Corps Inspector General David Kotz cited the lack of cooperation from the US embassy in Bolivia in the search for missing Peace Corps Volunteer Walter Poirier III. Now a member of the US Embassy Staff in Bolivia is accused of asking Peace Corps Volunteers "to basically spy" on Cubans and Venezuelans in the country. Could US Ambassador Philip S.Goldberg please explain what is going on at the embassy that he has been running in La Paz since 2006?



Read the stories and leave your comments.








Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.

Story Source: Newsweek

This story has been posted in the following forums: : Headlines; COS - Korea; COS - China; Figures; COS - Cameroon; Diplomacy

PCOL41692
31


Add a Message


This is a public posting area. Enter your username and password if you have an account. Otherwise, enter your full name as your username and leave the password blank. Your e-mail address is optional.
Username:  
Password:
E-mail: