September 29, 2003 - PCOL Exclusive: Winning the Hearts and Minds?

Peace Corps Online: Peace Corps News: Headlines: Peace Corps Headlines - 2003: September 2003 Peace Corps Headlines: September 29, 2003 - PCOL Exclusive: Winning the Hearts and Minds?

By Admin1 (admin) on Monday, September 29, 2003 - 12:28 pm: Edit Post

Winning the Hearts and Minds?





Read and comment on this op-ed written for "Peace Corps Online" by Thailand RPCV Collin Tong about the profoundly troubling questions for Returned Peace Corps Volunteers seeking to voice their concerns about the course of American foreign policy post Sept. 11th, and in particular the deteriorating humanitarian crisis in Iraq:
"On Feb. 14 and March 21, 2003, more than 1,850 RPCVs signed two New York Times ads urging a peaceful resolution of the crisis in Iraq and condemning unilateral U.S. action. We did so mindful of the reasons that inspired more than 165,000 Americans who have served abroad in 136 countries, i.e. to promote better understanding of other peoples in the world. In particular, we reaffirm the spirit articulated in the Third Goal of the Peace Corps Act - to help Americans understand the people and cultures of other countries -thereby making our country better informed and more engaged in world affairs."
John C. Rude perhaps said it best. In his article, "Why The Peace Corps Needs a Fourth Goal," Rude (RPCV Eritrea 1962-64), states: "The Fourth Goal states explicitly that peace is part of the agency's mission. Whatever else is "real" about global politics, we must address the fact that our capacity for killing is vastly greater than our capacity for healing. Read the op-ed at:

WINNING THE HEARTS AND MINDS?*

* This link was active on the date it was posted. PCOL is not responsible for broken links which may have changed.



WINNING THE HEARTS AND MINDS?

By Collin Tong

The U.S. Senate Appropriations Committee recently opened hearings into the Administration's request for $87 billion for the military and for Iraqi reconstruction on Sept. 22, 2003. At those hearings, Sen. Robert C. Byrd ( D. - W. VA.) asserted:

"In essence, America faces two wars at once: the war brought against us with the attacks of September 11, 2001, and the war that we brought to Iraq on March 19, 2003. The Iraqi war was the wrong war, for the wrong reasons, against the wrong enemy.

"It is a tragedy of American foreign policy that the sympathy which most of the world had for the United States after 9-11 has been squandered by the Bush Administration's headlong pursuit of an unnecessary preemptive war against a sovereign country, a country which posed no imminent and direct threat to our national security."

Sen. Byrd's observation raises profoundly troubling questions for Returned Peace Corps Volunteers seeking to voice their concerns about the course of American foreign policy post Sept. 11th, and in particular the deteriorating humanitarian crisis in Iraq.

In his op-ed, "Send in the Peace Corps" (July 23rd, New York Times) Avi M. Spiegel weighed in on that debate.

"The Peace Corps, America's oldest overseas volunteer program should equip itself to enter regions it now deems too dangerous," wrote Siegel (RPCV Morocco 1998-2000). "With Congress debating spending on the Peace Corps and Americorps, it is time to update the Peace Corps' mission."

His rationale: "Today the war on terror guides America's foreign policy, and it is all-encompassing. No nation is totally immune from danger. If it only allowed its volunteers in safe, stable countries, the Peace Corps would risk being shut out of too much of the world. The security situations in these countries may not change, but the Peace Corps can."

To many of us in the RPCV community, Spiegel's proposals signal the demise of Peace Corps' mission and a troubling, perhaps fatal, accommodation to the administration's National Security Strategy.

Released on Sept. 20, that document outlines a long-range plan for permanent U.S. military and economic preeminence in every region on the globe, unfettered by international treaty or concern. That policy, in effect, has committed the nation to preemptive military strikes in the perennial U.S.-declared war on terrorism.

On Feb. 14 and March 21, 2003, more than 1,850 RPCVs signed two New York Times ads urging a peaceful resolution of the crisis in Iraq and condemning unilateral U.S. action. We did so mindful of the reasons that inspired more than 165,000 Americans who have served abroad in 136 countries, i.e. to promote better understanding of other peoples in the world .

In particular, we reaffirm the spirit articulated in the Third Goal of the Peace Corps Act - to help Americans understand the people and cultures of other countries -thereby making our country better informed and more engaged in world affairs.

John C. Rude perhaps said it best. In his article, "Why The Peace Corps Needs a Fourth Goal," Rude (RPCV Eritrea 1962-64), states: "The Fourth Goal states explicitly that peace is part of the agency's mission. Whatever else is "real" about global politics, we must address the fact that our capacity for killing is vastly greater than our capacity for healing.

"The Peace Corps' pragmatic reason for existence is solely to make healing possible, thereby make killing seem unreasonable. The Fourth Goal recognizes that the Peace Corps is not merely an agency of government or an instrument of American foreign policy."

Sending in Peace Corps Volunteers, as Spiegel proposes, to Iraq, Afghanistan, and other nations where U.S. military forces are engaged in low-intensity conflict only reinforces the perception that the Peace Corps is an extension of U.S. foreign policy, albeit in the service of "winning the hearts and minds".

For that reason alone, it's hard to make the case to increase the size of Peace Corps in the post-9/11 world, if our only purpose is to bolster the ill-advised goal of expanding U.S. military bases in the Middle East and other regions around the globe.

One need only look at the aftermath of "Operation Iraqi Freedom" to understand the consequences of such a decision. Twelve years of U.S.-imposed economic sanctions followed by the unfolding quagmire of postwar occupation have only increased civilian suffering in Iraq.

"Since the (sanctions) program began," reports Joy Gordon in "Cool War: Economic Sanctions as a Weapon of Mass Destruction," (November 2002, Harper's) "an estimated 500,000 Iraqi children under the age of five have died as a result of the sanctions - almost three times as many as the number of Japanese killed during the U.S. atomic bomb attacks."

Yet Iraqi civilian casualties - many of them children -- from the war and sanctions continue to be ignored or underreported by the mainstream media, despite published reports by the United Nations and other humanitarian aid organizations.

"Perhaps it is a universal truth that the loss of liberty at home is to be charged to provisions against danger, real or pretended, from abroad," James Madison once wrote Thomas Jefferson in 1798.

"Truth is the first casualty of war," a journalist once wrote. Without informed public debate and civic engagement on the humanitarian consequences of the U.S.'s preemptive invasion of Iraq, not only is the White House emboldened to skirt any accountability for its decisions in the months ahead, but the possibilities for dissent are stifled.

Without informed public debate, an already inflamed tinderbox in the Middle East may easily ignite into an international conflagration the likes of which we can only hope will not happen.


About the Author



Collin Tong, senior director of news and communications at Washington State University, served as a Peace Corps Volunteer in Thailand from 1968 to 1969. Tong established Returned Peace Corps Volunteers for a Better World, a campaign of more than 1,850 RPCVs nationwide who signed the New York Times ads. For more information, see www.epic-usa.org/rpcv.




Click on a link below for more stories on PCOL

9/29/03
Sign Up for News

What's New?

Contact PCOL

Add Frames
Remove Frames

News Sections
PCOL Magazine
Breaking News


Directory Sections
RPCVs by COS
RPCVs by State
RPCVs by Interest


One World

Peace Corps Encyclopedia

Peace Corps Library
Advocacy
Appropriations
Awards
Bulletin Board
Cartoons
Congress
Critics
Directors
Downloads
Headlines
History
Humor
Lariam
Laws
Legislation
Letters
Local RPCV Groups
Lost RPCVs
Master Index
NPCA
Obituaries
Older Volunteers
PCVs
Photography
Prospective PCVs
RPCVs
Recruitment
Return to COS
Safety of PCVs
Service
Speaking Out
States
Stories
The Third Goal
Training
US Peace Corps
USA Freedom Corps
Writing




Peace Corps Online
...window on the world for RPCVs


PCOL Utilities
Getting Started
Formatting
Troubleshooting
Privacy
Copyright
Edit Profile
Fair Use
FAQ
Site Map
Contact PCOL




Keeping Kennedy's Promise




RPCVs remember
...the Peace Corps Fallen



Peace Corps Net
Crossroads
Volunteers
Groups


Peace Corps Online is an independent News Forum edited and published by Returned Peace Corps Volunteers and has no affilation or connection with the federal agency, the US Peace Corps.


All Rights Copyright © Peace Corps Online
Call your Senator about PC Appropriations

This Week's Top Stories

Peace Corps and the Environment 27 Sept
A Remembrance of Paul Conklin 25 Sept
Bush creates "Volunteers for Prosperity" 25 Sept
Peace Corps starts new Ad Campaign 25 Sept
Peace Corps returns to Albania 25 Sept
Peace Corps gets Web Site Makeover 24 Sept
Shays finds critical shortfalls at USAID 23 Sept

September Issue of PCOL Magazine

Which direction for the NPCA?
Read three different views on where the NPCA is headed: First our interview with NPCA President Kevin Quigley, then John Coyne's Modest Proposal for the NPCA, and finally our story on changes in NPCA's bylaws that some RPCVs have proposed.

Does Bush really support the Peace Corps?
What is the substance behind the President's rhetoric of support for the Peace Corps?

The Art of Being Globally Thrifty
Read Terez Rose's essay about one of the lessons she learned while in Africa - how to be patient and weather the storm of challenging times with dignity and grace.

Cultural Representation and the Peace Corps Museum
The Peace Corps Museum can be a place where cultures are respected with dignity, stories are told and where we can come together as a community.

Queer Eye for the Straight RPCV
Read the email from the casting director for the TV show "Queer Eye For The Straight Guy" who is looking for a recently Returned Volunteer to be on the show.

The Peace Corps Encyclopedia
Take a look at our new "Encyclopedia" of Peace Corps knowledge with information about over 100 categories.

Feature Stories from Recent Issues of PCOL

House of Representatives passes Charter
The Peace Corps and the Returned Volunteer community celebrated a big victory when the "Peace Corps Act for the 21st Century" Act passed the House in July. Read what's next for the bill.

Kevin Quigley named new NPCA President
The NPCA has selected the next generation of leadership for their organization. Read about the new President.

Investigation on death of PCV in Mali
The results of the investigation into the death of PCV Zachary Merrill in Mali.

President Bush meets PCVs in Botswana
The President met with PCVs in Botswana. Here's what he said.

Friends of Liberia issue a Call to Action
This RPCV group has a long history on involvement in efforts to bring peace to their Country of Service. Here's what they have to say about the present situation.

Issues with the Peace Corps Bill in Congress
Read about the differences between the House and Senate versions of the "Peace Corps Act for the 21st Century" and decide which one is better.

Americorps' Failure
Lessons the Peace Corps can learn from Americorps' problems.

RPCV is wheelchair basketball champion
The courage of a volunteer struck down by polio in Central America.

Watch Director Vasquez on web tv
See the Peace Corps Director speak to High School students in Maryland.

RPCVs dump ton of coal at US Capital
Read what the RPCV-led Chesapeake Climate Action Network is doing to educate the public on Global Warming.

German Peace Corps celebrates 40 years
The governance structure of the German Peace Corps differs from that of the US Peace Corps. Is it better?

Peace Corps to add 1,000 AIDS/HIV volunteers
Director Vasquez's new initiative to expand the Peace Corps in Africa.

The Digital Freedom Initiative
The innovative new program to wire Senegal.


For the Record: Top Stories in the last 30 days

Peace Corps and the Environment 27 Sept
A Remembrance of Paul Conklin 25 Sept
Bush creates "Volunteers for Prosperity" 25 Sept
Peace Corps starts new Ad Campaign 25 Sept
Peace Corps returns to Albania 25 Sept
Peace Corps gets Web Site Makeover 24 Sept
Barbara Ferris speaks at President's Forum 24 Sept
Collin Tong named to NPCA Board 24 Sept
Shays finds critical shortfalls at USAID 23 Sept
Peace Corps Giant Paul Conklin dies 20 Sept
RPCV McPherson returns from Iraq mission 19 Sept
PCVs in Swaziland for AIDS Education 17 Sept
RPCV appointed DNC Deputy Chair 16 Sept
Peace Corps gets new IT tools 16 Sept
Pierson in Nigeria: Peace Corps to return? 15 Sept
Kerry promotes Peace Corps service 15 Sept
Aliu praises Peace Corps AIDS efforts 15 Sept
Vasquez in Ghana for CD Conference 15 Sept
Glimpses of Afghanistan 14 Sept
RPCV 'Sam' Udall dies in Colorado 14 Sept
RPCV says to develop ties with world 11 Sept
Evaluating the Peace Corps 11 Sept
Howard Dean's brother planned to join PC 11 Sept
RPCVs lose ranch in Mexico 11 Sept
Schneider: Unilateralism inspires distrust 10 Sept
Lariam Failure blamed for Malaria outbreak 10 Sept
Friends of Liberia send message to Bush 10 Sept
Peace Corps Director Travels to Africa 10 Sept
RPCV says PC yields huge dividends 10 Sept
Eunice Shriver backs Schwarzenegger 10 Sept
PC Director Visits Namibia 10 Sept
RPCV's Engineering Assistance Network 9 Sept
Bush Should Listen Closely in Africa 7 Sept
DC, FON RPCVs push for new NPCA Board 7 Sept
Become an NPCA Advocate 5 Sept
NPCA President speaks out for Americorps 5 Sept
Interview with NPCA President Kevin Quigley 3 Sept
Visa Problems frustrate RPCV's wedding 3 Sept
Carol Bellamy's UNICEF in the crosshairs 2 Sept
RPCV Dave Thieson dies in Maryland 2 Sept
The Art of Being Globally Thrifty 1 Sept
RPCV founds Educare-Africa 1 Sept
RPCV says No Stability in Afghanistan 28 Aug
Bush meets with future PCVs 28 Aug
Senator Coleman to push to AIDS funding 28 Aug
Walsh won't support Americorps bailout 28 Aug
Former Director Chao profiled in USA Today 28 Aug

Top Discussion Stories

Accountability
Read why Senator Norm Coleman is a strong supporter of Bush's full $359M budget request but wants greater accountability from the Peace Corps.

The Fourth Goal
Sargent Shriver's Fourth Goal for the Peace Corps and his call for an enterprise that is vastly improved, expanded, and profoundly deeper.

A Volunteer's Courage
After Sara Evans was assaulted she left the Peace Corps and returned to the United States. But her ordeal was only beginning.

More Special Reports

Interview with Kevin Quigley
Our talk with the new NPCA President about his vision for the organization.

A Modest Proposal
Read the op-ed by John Coyne on how to expand and revitalize the NPCA and what you can do to help.

Send in the Peace Corps?
Should the Peace Corps be heading into Iraq and Afghanistan? What do you think?

Improvements needed
...in Volunteer services. Read our exclusive story on what needs to be done to support volunteers and reduce attrition rates.

Volunteer Safety
Read the GAO Report on Safety and Security of Volunteers.

Become a Peace Corps Advocate
Join the NPCA's nationwide network of RPCVs who will lobby Senators and Congressmen on behalf of Peace Corps legislation.

Peace Corps Charter
Read about the new Peace Corps bill going through Congress. Compare the Senate and House versions of the bill here.

The Numbers Game
Double the Peace Corps - but maintain the quality of the programs and the volunteer experience.

The Lariam Files
Read about the anti-malarial drug thousands of volunteers have taken - and its potential side effects.

Protest at the Peace Corps
Do volunteers and staff retain first amendment rights while working in the Peace Corps. Join the discussion.

RPCVs organize
Read how 1,800 RPCVs organized to place two half-page ads in the New York Times.

PC is "truly hardcore"
A Marine Sergeant visited his daughter who is serving in Nicaragua. Read what he says about the Peace Corps.

From Russia with Love
The story behind the departure of the Peace Corps from Russia.

RPCVs honor Vaughn
Returned Volunteers met to honor and listen to the wisdom of Peace Corps legend Jack Vaughn.

The IDPA: PC Forerunner
The IDPA, a forerunner of the Peace Corps, created in 1951 to place people with indigenous organizations and governments in Africa, Asia, and Latin America.

Alcohol Abuse a big issue for PCVs in Central Asia
Read about the health hazard PC Staff is warning volunteers in former Soviet Republics about.

PC/Washington: Senior Staff Appointments at PC HQ
See if you can guess how many Returned Volunteers there are in the top 21 senior staff positions (political appointees) at Peace Corps Headquarters.

Peace Corps TV Show
Last year Fox network created a pilot for a tv show about a Returned Peace Corps Volunteer. Although the show wasn't picked up, read RPCVs' many humourous suggestions for the title.

RPCV Spy dies in Moscow
The strange story of the RPCV who defected to Russia.

The Shrivers: A Special Legacy
The Founding Director of the Peace Corps and his future plans.

Bill Moyers on America's Future
Read what an early Peace Corps Deputy Director says about America's future.

Op-ed: The Future of the Peace Corps
Does the Peace Corps have a future in the age of the American Imperium? What do you think?

The Case for PC Independence
Why the USA Freedom Corps doesn't make sense.

Preservation of an Independent Peace Corps
Returned Volunteers insist that the Peace Corps must remain an independent agency to do its job.



Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.

This story has been posted in the following forums: : Headlines; Speaking Out; Iraq

PCOL7962
74

.

By Terry Adcock Colombia 1961-63 on Thursday, October 02, 2003 - 11:50 pm: Edit Post

When I served in the Peace Corps, it was an extension of American Foreign Policy, but American Foreign Policy included the search for Peace in the midst of hostility.

Today, post 9/11, I look in vain for any part of American Foreign Policy that includes the search for Peace. All I see is militaristic jingoism and a contempt for the world community that defies comprehension.

That is why I was so grateful to Collin Tong for initiating the New York Times advertisement that harkened back to the original Peace Corps ideals, while the whole country, including four of the ten current candidates for the Democratic Party's nomination for President, rushed toward the invasion of Iraq on trumped-up grounds.

I signed that statement in the New York Times. There wouldn't have been anything to sign without Collin's wonderful organizational activities.

Collin, you are clearly living out the Peace Corps ideals as an RPCV. I admire your hard work. Thank you from the bottom of my heart.


Add a Message


This is a public posting area. Enter your username and password if you have an account. Otherwise, enter your full name as your username and leave the password blank. Your e-mail address is optional.
Username:  
Password:
E-mail: