April 11, 2005: Headlines: Figures: COS - Uzbekistan: Writing - Uzbekistan: COS - Kyrgyzstan: Alternet: An Interview with RPCV Tom Bissell on recent events in Kyrgyzstan: "It had become a distressing situation and I知 happy with the events in Kyrgyzstan, but it is unfortunate that the one guy who least deserved it has been chased out of his country."

Peace Corps Online: Directory: Kyrgyzstan: Peace Corps Kyrgyzstan : The Peace Corps in Kyrgyzstan: April 11, 2005: Headlines: Figures: COS - Uzbekistan: Writing - Uzbekistan: COS - Kyrgyzstan: Alternet: An Interview with RPCV Tom Bissell on recent events in Kyrgyzstan: "It had become a distressing situation and I知 happy with the events in Kyrgyzstan, but it is unfortunate that the one guy who least deserved it has been chased out of his country."

By Admin1 (admin) (pool-151-196-181-108.balt.east.verizon.net - on Wednesday, April 13, 2005 - 7:29 pm: Edit Post

An Interview with RPCV Tom Bissell on recent events in Kyrgyzstan: "It had become a distressing situation and I知 happy with the events in Kyrgyzstan, but it is unfortunate that the one guy who least deserved it has been chased out of his country."

An Interview with RPCV Tom Bissell on recent events in Kyrgyzstan: It had become a distressing situation and I知 happy with the events in Kyrgyzstan, but it is unfortunate that the one guy who least deserved it has been chased out of his country.

An Interview with RPCV Tom Bissell on recent events in Kyrgyzstan: "It had become a distressing situation and I知 happy with the events in Kyrgyzstan, but it is unfortunate that the one guy who least deserved it has been chased out of his country."

Revolution, Interrupted

By Ben Bush, AlterNet. Posted April 11, 2005.

The Kyrgyz uprising may not result in the Democratic flowering that the West would like to see. Author Tom Bissell takes a cold, hard look at where the small Central Asian state has been, and where it might be going.

A mere three weeks after a mass uprising which resulted in a parliamentary upheaval, little Kyrgyzstan seems to have faded into the background -- losing ground to the Pope and Terri Schiavo.

The former Soviet republic, sandwiched between Kazakhstan and China, has been the site of what many have been calling a democratic revolution comparable to those seen in Georgia and Ukraine. After observers reported rigged parliamentary elections, an uprising began in the southern part of the country and quickly spread to its capital, Bishkek. On March 24th protesters raided the presidential compound and president Askar Akayev fled to Russia and later resigned in a videotaped speech.

After the initial fanfare, the bloom may be off the rose. As politicians vye for power in the new government, the democratic ideals that may have sparked the uprising are getting short shrift. Meanwhile, the West's attention lags; Kyrgyzstan is of little strategic interest, aside from its potential to spark a Democracy domino effect throughout Central Asia.

Author Tom Bissell has focused his fiction and nonfiction energies at the Central Asian region. Once a Peace Corps volunteer in Uzbekistan, he has gone on to publish two books about the post-Soviet republics of Central Asia. His first, a travelogue called Chasing the Sea, encompasses everything from environmental disaster tourism to smuggling money to the families of dissident journalists, all of it set to a soundtrack of pirated copies of Eminem and Depeche Mode. His most recently work, God Lives in St. Petersburg, is a collection of short stories about the region. His writing is full of uncomfortable truths, brilliant dexterous language and skeptical of any and all political ideology. He speaks with Ben Bush on the lingering effects of Soviet domination, rampant corruption, religion and American influence.

Ben Bush: In your book Chasing the Sea, you have a fairly positive portrayal of [former Kyrgyz president Askar] Akayev, how has that changed in light of recent events?

Tom Bissell: As relatively liberal as Akayev was, he came of political age in the Soviet system, which was as corrupt and perilous an environment as any, and I think in recent years he began to look around at his fellow Central Asian autocrats and dictators and realize that his slightly more open approach to governance wasn稚 doing him or his country any good. Rather than have the life of an admirable failure, he just decided to grab onto everything he could. Kyrgyzstan had been known as the nicest place to go to in Central Asia, where the cops were least likely to shake you down, and I think a lot of people attribute that to the atmosphere Akayev had created, but I have been really shocked by the corruption of the last four years. It had become a distressing situation and I知 happy with the events in Kyrgyzstan, but it is unfortunate that the one guy who least deserved it has been chased out of his country. Karimov, Turkmenbashi, or Nazarbayev I would have preferred to see any one of those three go. It does seem Kyrgyzstan is in a bit of a jam, and it痴 very nerve-racking to see what痴 going to happen next.

In Chasing the Sea, you mention that Akayev decried the 1991 coup against Gorbachev in which hard-line communist factions were trying to seize power and halt reform. Did that help prevent the success of that coup or was it that at a moment when power was up for grabs Akayev was standing on the side of reform?

Gorbachev was kidnapped and the cover story was that he was sick and they were looking into it when, in fact, Communist hard-liners were taking over. While the other Central Asian nations just sort of gutlessly shat themselves and waited to see what happened, to Akayev痴 immense credit, Kyrgyzstan was among the first to dissolve the Communist Party and declare independence. A lot of people had their finest moment at that time, Yeltsin among them, and it痴 just a shame that they never showed anything approaching that kind of bravery thereafter.

It seems like maybe one of the most glaring contradictions in the current uprising or whatever it痴 to be called is that what sparked the protests were botched parliamentary elections and yet despite the overturn of the presidency, the new parliament resulting from these potentially rigged elections has just been instated ahead of schedule. It makes it difficult to see this as too hopeful of a change there.

Under the Soviet system there was this group of a select few relatively well off people, Vlasti is the word--people in academia, in the media, in economics--and for the most part all were Communist party members. They were all taken care of, got rich, and lived lives that were a lot better than everyone else's. When the Soviet Union collapsed everyone hoped the Vlasti were either going to come down to other people痴 standards a little bit or lift other people up to theirs, but in Central Asia, for the most part, the Vlasti basically still control everything. The Vlasti all managed to survive the Soviet meltdown. Imagine that! Everything that came out in the early '90s and late '80s: all the horror, all the stuff that people were finally able to talk about, every single one of those bastards survived. And here痴 the joke: a decade and a half later they池e still there. Pardon my French, but they池e motherfuckers. What it痴 going to take to kick them out I have no idea.

There痴 a comment in your book about Kyrgyzstan making 59 percent of what it did in the final years of Communism. How does that affect sentiments regarding the shift to a market economy there?

I don稚 think the reduced GDP has anything to do with the shift to capitalism, I think it has to do with corruption. I知 not one of these market economy voodoo witch doctors who thinks it fixes everything, but every single person in Central Asia is a market economist par excellence. If you致e ever walked through a bazaar in that place, these people are traders right down to their molecules and atoms. They know how to sell. The anger toward the stagnation is not ideological and it痴 not economic. I think it痴 just a very real frustration that the only people who seem to make any money in that part of the world are people who are willing to do really horrible, unspeakable things to do it. I call it 鼎apitalismoid. It is kind of a market economy, I guess, but without the varying levels of trust underneath it, that we all operate on in this country. There痴 just a whole bunch of social contracts that we have that allows us to practice capitalism with a human face and it痴 not even that human of a face all the time. Imagine commerce practiced with utter brutality and I think you壇 have an idea of what痴 going on in Central Asia.

There痴 been some talk about the North-South divide in Kyrgyzstan and its implications for the region痴 long-term stability. Journalists depict the south as poorer than the already very poor north, more rural, more Islamic and with a large population of ethnic Uzbeks. What do you see as the significance of that divide?

They池e more mountain people. They池e less educated. This has been the first time I致e ever really heard about this divide. Every country has its geographic differences, of course, but that sounds suspiciously like one of those journalistic shibboleths people make up to talk about -- the specter of civil war in Kyrgyzstan -- and a lot of these people frankly don稚 know what the hell they池e talking about. I see western commentators just kind of blithely talking about civil war coming to this or that place when they致e obviously just spent the last two hours reading Google links. It痴 just instant punditry, you just put it in the microwave.

The protests that sparked the ousting of Akayev began in southern part of the country in Osh. In Chasing the Sea, you mention an Uzbek-Kyrgyz race riot there?

There was a riot in the market that started because of an argument over strawberries, if you can believe that. Someone felt they were being overcharged by an Uzbek market person, a riot started and it went on for weeks. At least, that痴 the story. Hundreds of people were killed. When I visited Osh and I asked about it, everyone basically said, 的t痴 over. It痴 forgotten. Keep in mind that this happened at the tail end of the Soviet Union, a time of extreme tension and absolute worry on the part of everybody who lived there about what the hell was going to happen. So, if there were ever going to be a race riots in a city in a country that has a huge ethnic minority from a neighboring country in one of its biggest cities謡ell, that probably would have been the time.

In Saudi Arabia and in the Middle East there痴 been hostility towards American bases there. Is there a potential for that kind of thing in Kyrgyzstan, with a large U.S. base there? Is this a different situation entirely?

I致e said this again and again: in my experience, by and large, the people of Central Asia are not easily radicalizable Islamically. If you erase the wider cultural presence of a religion for seven decades as the Soviets did it痴 bound to affect people痴 religiosity. The people I know--even the ones who are religious--have very little interest in doctrinaire Islam. I mean almost none and I致e talked to people who teach Arabic in madrassas [religious schools]. There might be some kind of generic hostility towards the United States, but never anything that would compel them to pick up a Kalashnikov. I just think it痴 totally overstated, totally exaggerated by a lot of Western commentators. And you know what? If I知 wrong and a war breaks out, some reincarnation of Enver Pasha comes back and leads the jihad against the West, I will happily say, 釘oy, did I fuck that up. I知 pretty confident in my view that radicalized Islam in Central Asia is almost not worth worrying about.

The New York Times talks about 渡ear-secular Islam in Kyrgyzstan and in Chasing the Sea you comment that 典he Kyrgyz relationship to Islam was vernacular, more oral mythological than political. Is this just the aftereffects of Soviet policies which suppressed religion?

The Kyrgyz did not adopt Islam until the 16th century. They were nomadic mountain worshippers before that and they were never really that into Islam anyway. The Krygyz have more Chinese cultural background than a lot of the other parts of Central Asia and there痴 just a lot more quasi-pagan and quasi-nomadic sprinklings in their interpretation of Islam. It痴 a combination of the historically more moderate Turkic influence on Islam, combined with the Russian persecution of Islam.

What do you make of Freedom House Press, the U.S. funded printing house which has been assisting the publishing efforts of the oppositional parties there? A picture of a lavish summer home Akayev was having built in particular is said to have precipitated the protests. Do you see U.S. involvement as genuinely contributing to the growth of democracy there?

I applaud the United States for its involvement in the Ukraine and Georgia because I really think they were on the right people痴 side. I am intensely cynical and distrustful of the United States involvement in Central Asia, if only for their proven willingness to abet leaders who literally boil their own people alive. The people in the State Department know the torture that goes on there and September 11th was like the worst disaster imaginable for democratic reformers in Central Asia. The U.S. brokering deals with these governments just legitimized all these guys to an even greater extent. In my experience and from what I致e heard, every embassy in Central Asia has two factions in it: the He痴 a bastard, but he痴 our bastard crowd and the We have to do something to make this better crowd, and these people are often at each others throats. Like I said, I知 very cynical about what the United States has been willing to condone when it comes to Central Asian leaders and I certainly don稚 think they went to take over the place for its oil or gas or anything like that but I do think that as long as they致e got these bases, as long as they池e able to stage strikes out of these nations on the remnants of Al Qaeda, I知 fairly sure there痴 almost nothing the current administration wouldn稚 overlook.

My impression is Kyrgyzstan itself isn稚 rich with oil or gas and it doesn稚 seem like it would be useful to put a Western pipeline in. It痴 on the wrong side of the Caspian oil reserves.

What Kyrgyzstan has most notably is just immense natural beauty, and very pleasant weather for six months of the year.

There痴 the Manas Air Force Base just outside of the Kyrgyz capital of Bishkek which is the largest U.S. base in Central Asia. Did you see the effects of that kind of thing, the U.S./Western presence over there?

I don稚 think people there as a whole have any resentment whatsoever towards the Western presence. I think they welcome it. It痴 not Vietnam. This is not American soldiers turning an entire generation of 15-to-23-year old girls into prostitutes. That痴 just not going to happen there. All the prostitutes that are in central Asia were already there thanks to the Russians. Thank you very much. Central Asia has been pre-corrupted, if you know what I mean. Everything bad that was going to happen to Central Asian culture already happened and the Russians did it, the Soviets did it. We are a love bite compared to the damage Soviet culture inflicted upon the indigenous people of Central Asia. The only people bothered by the Western presence are either basement terrorists or 89-year-old hard-core ideological Communists. That痴 my opinion. Fairly informed opinion but opinion all the same.

There痴 a couple of different reactionary versions of what痴 going on and one is that it痴 a triumph of democracy which doesn稚 seem dead on to me and the other is that it痴 some sort of Western conspiracy.

Are people really saying it痴 a Western conspiracy? I think if you really look at a cost benefit analysis of this stuff and when you weigh it the way a president or a department of state guy is really going to think about these countries-- Just put yourself in his position, no one was sitting around talking about Kyrgyzstan when this happened. Trust me, they weren稚. What I hate about thoughtless anti-Americanism is the same thing I hate about thoughtless pro-Americanism. They池e essentially the same position: nothing happens that America didn稚 create or cause. It痴 the same delusion. It just boggles my mind that Noam Chomsky and George Bush basically have the same worldview, one is a transvestite of the other.

It痴 like the right using Lebanon to vindicate their policy in Iraq. It would be foolish to say they池e completely unrelated but it would be equally foolish to say they池e inexorably related. People say Ronald Reagan won the cold war. That痴 the biggest load of fucking horseshit anyone has ever peddled. The Soviets had so many problems. The fact that Reagan happened to expand our military at the moment when the Soviet Union痴 unworkable system was finally collapsing on itself, and that collapse had almost nothing to do with Reagan. It was incidental. There was a million tributaries--cultural, political, historical--leading to the USSR痴 collapse. It痴 folly to go around looking at these events in the interest of figuring out how they benefit whatever president or political party happens to be in power. It痴 actually kind of evil, as all it does is create this vision of America as the puppet-master. The right can稚 have it both ways: they can稚 decry all this leftist conspiracy talk and then just take credit for every good thing that happens as a result of their own policy. It doesn稚 make sense. It痴 the simplest contradiction you can imagine.

Ben Bush is a frequent contributor to Bitch, Kitchen Sink and XLR8R.

When this story was posted in April 2005, this was on the front page of PCOL:

Peace Corps Online The Independent News Forum serving Returned Peace Corps Volunteers
The Peace Corps Library Date: March 27 2005 No: 536 The Peace Corps Library
Peace Corps Online is proud to announce that the Peace Corps Library is now available online. With over 30,000 index entries in 500 categories, this is the largest collection of Peace Corps related stories in the world. From Acting to Zucchini, you can find hundreds of stories about what RPCVs with your same interests or from your Country of Service are doing today. If you have a web site, support the "Peace Corps Library" and link to it today.

Top Stories and Breaking News PCOL Magazine Peace Corps Library RPCV Directory Sign Up

RPCVs and Friends remember Pope John Paul II Date: April 3 2005 No: 550 RPCVs and Friends remember Pope John Paul II
Tony Hall found the pope to be courageous and capable of forgiving the man who shot him in 1981, Mark Gearan said the pope was as dynamic in person as he appears on television, Maria Shriver said he was a beacon of virtue, strength and goodness, and an RPCV who met the pope while serving in the Solomon Islands said he possessed the holiness of a man filled with a deep love and concern for humanity. Leave your thoughts here.

Friends of the Peace Corps 170,000  strong Date: April 2 2005 No: 543 Friends of the Peace Corps 170,000 strong
170,000 is a very special number for the RPCV community - it's the number of Volunteers who have served in the Peace Corps since 1961. It's also a number that is very special to us because March is the first month since our founding in January, 2001 that our readership has exceeded 170,000. And while we know that not everyone who comes to this site is an RPCV, they are all "Friends of the Peace Corps." Thanks everybody for making PCOL your source of news for the Returned Volunteer community.

April 10, 2005: This Week's Top Stories Date: April 10 2005 No: 555 April 10, 2005: This Week's Top Stories
The Coyne Column: "Why do you study Jesuits?" 10 Apr
Al Kamen says Condi Rice is Baffled 8 Apr
Chris Dodd makes "sneak attack" on AgustaWestland 7 Apr
Accused attacker maintains innocence 7 Apr
Jim Walsh supports Sinn Féin declaration 7 Apr
Crisis Corps team in Thailand begins work 6 Apr
Tom Weisner wins big in Aurora Mayor's Race 6 Apr
BBDO wins EFFIE Ad Awards for "Life is Calling" 6 Apr
PCVs removed after missionaries killed in Guyana 5 Apr
Chris Matthews covers death of Pope John Paul II 5 Apr
24 Congressmen sign Peace Corps letter 4 Apr
Update: PCVs in Kyrgyzstan back in communities 4 Apr
Tom Murphy lays into Bush administration 4 Apr
Bellamy urges legislators to protect children 4 Apr
Lynn Olson manages art gallery after judgeship 4 Apr
Bob Taft promotes tax code overhaul in Ohio 3 Apr
Richard Kaminski lost in village in Botswana 3 Apr

April 10, 2005: Events around the Country Date: April 10 2005 No: 552 April 10, 2005: Events around the Country
North Carolina RPCV discusses Nepal trek on April 14 6 Apr
South Carolina RPCVs to see off PCVs on April 18 5 Apr
Gaddi Vasquez speaks at Northwestern University 6 Apr
Henry McKoy speaks at Clemson University 8 Apr
Minnesota RPCVs need Photos for Exhibition 24 Mar
Maryland RPCVs eat crab cakes in Annapolis 17 Mar
RPCVs: Post your stories or press releases here for inclusion next week.

April Feature Stories - only on PCOL Date: April 10 2005 No: 553 April Feature Stories - only on PCOL
Dream Come True - Revisiting India after 34 years
The Coyne Column: Read Winning Vanity Fair PCV Essay
Tomas Belsky's paintings inspired by service in Brazil
RPCV reunites with friend after 40 years
RPCV reviews "Los Heraldos Negros" by Cesar Vallejo
Photo Essay: Taking it to the Streets

Crisis Corps arrives in Thailand Date: March 20 2005 No: 530 Crisis Corps arrives in Thailand
After the Tsunami in Southeast Asia last December, Peace Corps issued an appeal for Crisis Corps Volunteers and over 200 RPCVs responded. The first team of 8 Crisis Corps volunteers departed for Thailand on March 18 to join RPCVs who are already supporting relief efforts in Sri Lanka, Indonesia, Thailand, Malaysia, and India with other agencies and NGO's.

RPCVs in Congress ask colleagues to support PC Date: March 5 2005 No: 482 RPCVs in Congress ask colleagues to support PC
RPCVs Sam Farr, Chris Shays, Thomas Petri, James Walsh, and Mike Honda have asked their colleagues in Congress to add their names to a letter they have written to the House Foreign Operations Subcommittee, asking for full funding of $345 M for the Peace Corps in 2006. As a follow-on to Peace Corps week, please read the letter and call your Representative in Congress and ask him or her to add their name to the letter.

Add your info now to the RPCV Directory Date: March 13 2005 No: 489 Add your info now to the RPCV Directory
Call Harris Publishing at 800-414-4608 right away to add your name or make changes to your listing in the newest edition of the NPCA's Directory of Peace Corps Volunteers and Former Staff. Then read our story on how you can get access to the book after it is published. The deadline for inclusion is May 16 so call now.

March 1: National Day of Action Date: February 28 2005 No: 471 March 1: National Day of Action
Tuesday, March 1, is the NPCA's National Day of Action. Please call your Senators and ask them to support the President's proposed $27 Million budget increase for the Peace Corps for FY2006 and ask them to oppose the elimination of Perkins loans that benefit Peace Corps volunteers from low-income backgrounds. Follow this link for step-by-step information on how to make your calls. Then take our poll and leave feedback on how the calls went.

Read the stories and leave your comments.

Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.

Story Source: Alternet

This story has been posted in the following forums: : Headlines; Figures; COS - Uzbekistan; Writing - Uzbekistan; COS - Kyrgyzstan



Add a Message

This is a public posting area. Enter your username and password if you have an account. Otherwise, enter your full name as your username and leave the password blank. Your e-mail address is optional.