2008.08.16: August 16, 2008: Headlines: Figures: COS - Morocco: COS - Afghanistan: Journalism: Globe and Mail: Sarah Chayes writes: Afghans don't support the insurgency; they're its primary targets

Peace Corps Online: Directory: Afghanistan: Special Report: Writer, Journalist, and AID Worker Sarah Chayes (RPCV Morocco) and her work in Afghanistan: Sarah Chayes: Newest Stories: 2008.08.16: August 16, 2008: Headlines: Figures: COS - Morocco: COS - Afghanistan: Journalism: Globe and Mail: Sarah Chayes writes: Afghans don't support the insurgency; they're its primary targets

By Admin1 (admin) (70.135.11.140) on Friday, August 22, 2008 - 11:01 am: Edit Post

Sarah Chayes writes: Afghans don't support the insurgency; they're its primary targets

Sarah Chayes writes: Afghans don't support the insurgency; they're its primary targets

Three days ago, the governor of Ghazni province was ambushed on the main road to Kabul and barely escaped alive. In the village where one of my co-operative members was born, Taliban are using what was the school as the gallows. In the past two weeks, one suspected anti-Taliban spy was hanged. A second was beaten till he cried out a confession, then also hanged, dollar bills stuffed in his mouth. When the Taliban wished to strip the body so it would hang shamefully naked for the two days during which they forbade relatives to cut it down and bury it, the villagers protested. "Sit down and shut up," came the answer. "Your turn is coming." Then a 16-year old was hanged from the feet and shot. His crime? Working as an apprentice to the driver of a truck carrying humanitarian wheat to Kandahar. Where another of my co-operative members lives, a baker who sold bread to soldiers, a school principal, and a former government worker were abducted last week. The Afghans do not support this so-called insurgency. They are its primary targets. Morocco RPCV Sarah Chayes has made a home in Kandahar, Afghanistan, became fluent in Pashto, one of the main Afghan languages, and devoted her energies to rebuilding a country gutted by two decades of war.

Sarah Chayes writes: Afghans don't support the insurgency; they're its primary targets

The perils of delivering aid

Afghans don't support the insurgency; they're its primary targets

SARAH CHAYES

From Friday's Globe and Mail

August 15, 2008 at 6:38 AM EDT

KANDAHAR — The gunning down of three female foreign aid workers - two of them Canadians - and their Afghan driver a few dozen miles south of Kabul on Wednesday is the latest bloody murder to underscore the relentless deterioration in Afghan security conditions.

Here in beleaguered Kandahar - where I have lived for nearly seven years and currently run a small soap-making co-operative - what most distressed my co-op members was the gender of the victims. "Women?" Nurallah pronounced, aghast. "They're killing women? These people can't be Afghans. If my worst enemy - my own personal enemy - came into my hands, but his wife was present, I wouldn't touch him. I would let him go."

On that point, Canadians and Afghans can agree.

Western coverage has brought to light other areas, however, where Afghan and international perceptions of this tragedy diverge.

Humanitarian immunity: Every news article I've read has stressed that the slain humanitarian workers' car was "clearly marked" with their organization's emblem - as if that should protect the passengers. But I fear humanitarian organizations are failing to recognize the transformations in this country since the 1980s and 1990s that have profoundly altered their status. These organizations take their own good intentions for granted, and expect beneficiaries to do the same. They are used to their outsider status and their declared neutrality guaranteeing safe passage across the battle lines of societies in conflict.

This conflict, however, is different. Neither the forces fighting the Afghan government, nor ordinary people, make any distinction between international humanitarian workers, the Afghan government, and international military forces. All are seen as part of the same system.

The vast majority of regular folk desire the presence of these interlocking groups. Afghans have serious criticisms to level against the corruption of government officials, the ways in which development aid is being spent, and the sometimes reckless behaviour of international troops. But by and large they want us here. Anti-government forces, however, are just as hostile to aid workers as they are to soldiers or government officials. The only place as dangerous to be as a NATO military convoy is a clearly marked humanitarian vehicle.

Danger to aid workers: Western media coverage has emphasized that danger to aid workers is shutting down delivery of humanitarian and development assistance. The victims' employer, the International Rescue Committee, is temporarily suspending its operations, for example.

But the most important constraint on aid work is the risk it poses to Afghans. Many villages in Kandahar have been refusing development assistance for several years now. They are afraid that the mere acceptance of these projects will transform their homes into targets. Recently, villagers to the west of town sent a delegation to the Taliban to explain that the repairs they were about to make to their irrigation channel were not a development project. The Taliban leaders replied: "If we find out you used a tractor lent to you by the government, we will burn it and kill you."

Afghan death toll: It is normal for people to feel most keenly the tragedies that strike people they know or can easily identify with. For precisely this reason, while bowing before the grief of the families of Wednesday's victims, I would like to share some stories you may not have heard.

Three days ago, the governor of Ghazni province was ambushed on the main road to Kabul and barely escaped alive. In the village where one of my co-operative members was born, Taliban are using what was the school as the gallows. In the past two weeks, one suspected anti-Taliban spy was hanged. A second was beaten till he cried out a confession, then also hanged, dollar bills stuffed in his mouth. When the Taliban wished to strip the body so it would hang shamefully naked for the two days during which they forbade relatives to cut it down and bury it, the villagers protested. "Sit down and shut up," came the answer. "Your turn is coming." Then a 16-year old was hanged from the feet and shot. His crime? Working as an apprentice to the driver of a truck carrying humanitarian wheat to Kandahar. Where another of my co-operative members lives, a baker who sold bread to soldiers, a school principal, and a former government worker were abducted last week.

The Afghans do not support this so-called insurgency. They are its primary targets.

Sarah Chayes is the founder of Arghand, a soap-making co-operative in Kandahar. She is also the author of "The Punishment of Virtue: Inside Afghanistan After the Taliban".




Links to Related Topics (Tags):

Headlines: August, 2008; RPCV Sarah Chayes (Morocco); Figures; Peace Corps Morocco; Directory of Morocco RPCVs; Messages and Announcements for Morocco RPCVs; Peace Corps Afghanistan; Directory of Afghanistan RPCVs; Messages and Announcements for Afghanistan RPCVs; Journalism





When this story was posted in August 2008, this was on the front page of PCOL:




Peace Corps Online The Independent News Forum serving Returned Peace Corps Volunteers RSS Feed
PCVs Evacuated from Georgia Date: August 19 2008 No: 1254 PCVs Evacuated from Georgia
The Peace Corps has announced that all Volunteers and trainees serving in the Republic of Georgia are safe and they have been temporarily relocated to neighboring Armenia. Read the analysis by one RPCV on how Georgia's President Mikheil Saakashvili believed that he could launch a lightning assault on South Ossetia and reclaim the republic without substantial grief from Moscow and that Saakashvili's statements once the war began demonstrated that he expected real Western help in confronting Russia.


 Contact PCOL Search PCOL with Google Site Index Recent Posts Bulletin Board Open Discussion RPCV Directory Register
Dodd vows to filibuster Surveillance Act Date: October 27 2007 No: 1206 Dodd vows to filibuster Surveillance Act
Senator Chris Dodd vowed to filibuster the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act that would grant retroactive immunity to telecommunications companies that helped this administration violate the civil liberties of Americans. "It is time to say: No more. No more trampling on our Constitution. No more excusing those who violate the rule of law. These are fundamental, basic, eternal principles. They have been around, some of them, for as long as the Magna Carta. They are enduring. What they are not is temporary. And what we do not do in a time where our country is at risk is abandon them."

August 6, 2008: This Month's Top Stories Date: August 6 2008 No: 1250 August 6, 2008: This Month's Top Stories
PC in Budget Crunch may cut PCVs by 5% 5 Aug
Garamendi first to announce run for governor in 2010 2 Aug
Bob and Pat Parish receive president’s award 31 Jul
Sam Brownback removes block on Kathleen Stephens 31 Jul
Peace Corps Removes Ban on HIV-Positive Volunteers 31 Jul
RPCVs organize online for Obama 31 Jul
Peace group awards perfect rating to Sam Farr 29 Jul
How Hill used back channels to negotiate Korean agreement 27 Jul
Voter surge may hurt Shays 26 Jul
Matthew A. Hamilton writes: A Shadow on Ararat 25 Jul
Gates says Tools of inspiration are indispensable 15 Jul
An interview with Composer Gabriela Lena Frank 13 Jul
Ginny Farmer to swim in Olympics for American Samoa 11 Jul
Dodd is possible vice presidential candidate 11 Jul
Carl Pope supports the Pickens Plan 8 Jul
George Packer writes: Obama’s Iraq Problem 7 Jul
An Interview with PCOL 4 Jul
Ifugao hopes for tourism boost after Campbell Trial 3 Jul
Peace Corps To Quit Kiribati 3 Jul
Tony Hall asks: Where is moral outrage over food crisis? 3 Jul
Wofford raises awareness about global poverty 2 Jul

New: More Stories from June and July 2008

July 1, 2008: This Month's Top Stories Date: July 16 2008 No: 1245 July 1, 2008: This Month's Top Stories
Sarah Chayes continues work in Kandahar 29 Jun
PCV Catherine Saltwick killed in Automobile Accident 2 Jun
Richard Stoll returns to Tonga for capitol’s rebuild 2 Jun
Peace Corps Reopens Program in Liberia 4 Jun
Tu Dang is a Foreign Affairs Officer 4 Jun
Bethany Hedt takes aim at AIDS with statistics 5 Jun
Expanding opportunities for deaf PCVs 5 Jun
Peace Corps/Kenya Program Reopening 6 Jun
José Klein is plate artist 9 Jun
Kenyan Prime Minister Visits PC Headquarters 19 Jun
Michael Meyer's writes "The Last Days of Old Beijing" 20 Jun
Chuck Ludlam writes: Congress Enacts PCV Tax Law 24 Jun
Dodd Speaks in Opposition to FISA Bill 24 Jun
Christopher Hill critical to success in Korea Talks 25 Jun
Mark Gearan writes: Hillary Clinton's Contribution 25 Jun
James Rupert writes: Pakistan Fights Taliban 27 Jun
Elaine Chao hails U.S.-China dialogue 28 Jun
Obituary for Bud Keith - Champion for Disabled 29 Jun
Life in prison for killer of PCV Julia Campbell 30 Jun
John Coyne writes: PC Archives at JFK Library 30 Jun
Mark Shriver to Chair National Commission on Children 30 Jun

New: More Stories from May and June 2008

June 1, 2008: This Month's Top Stories Date: July 16 2008 No: 1247 June 1, 2008: This Month's Top Stories
Senator ties up Kathleen Stephens appointment 1 May
Philip Dacey writes "The New York Postcard Sonnets" 31 May
Sophia Polasky writes: Luncheon with the president 30 May
Arnold Wendroff warns dangers of ritual use of mercury 30 May
Lynn Lurie writes “Corner of the Dead" 29 May
Obama Urges Grads To Serve Country 26 May
Nick Mucha promotes development at surf destinations 25 May
Don Crosby and wife serve in Thailand at 70 23 May
Matthew Handley pursued case of 12 murdered Nepalis 22 May
Zig and Irma Sokolnicki receive President's Award 21 May
Bruce Sterling writes: Steve Cisler RIP 20 May
Colorado to host Peace Corps Reunion in August 19 May
Hugh Pickens writes: Death Be Not Proud 17 May
Zachery Scott writes: Being a gay volunteer 14 May
PCVs in China Are Safe after earthquake 12 May
Louis Adams relives PC days in Morocco 12 May
Jemison say US leaders have made foolish decisions 11 May
Amy Smith's low-tech inventions have high impact 8 May
Bill Moyers on the 2008 Elections 8 May
Don Odermann creates Education Fund for Latin Players 5 May
Peter Hessler wins National Magazine Award 2 May

New: More Stories from April and May 2008



Read the stories and leave your comments.








Some postings on Peace Corps Online are provided to the individual members of this group without permission of the copyright owner for the non-profit purposes of criticism, comment, education, scholarship, and research under the "Fair Use" provisions of U.S. Government copyright laws and they may not be distributed further without permission of the copyright owner. Peace Corps Online does not vouch for the accuracy of the content of the postings, which is the sole responsibility of the copyright holder.

Story Source: Globe and Mail

This story has been posted in the following forums: : Headlines; Figures; COS - Morocco; COS - Afghanistan; Journalism

PCOL42037
93


Add a Message


This is a public posting area. Enter your username and password if you have an account. Otherwise, enter your full name as your username and leave the password blank. Your e-mail address is optional.
Username:  
Password:
E-mail: